1. Keeping Children and Adults Safe
    Click Here for more information!
    Dismiss Notice
  2. What do you do if you have a loved one missing?
    In this section, you will find tips on what to do and not do.
    Easily find organizations that you can contact for help.
    Click here for more information
    Dismiss Notice
  3. “We can't help everyone, but everyone can help someone.”
    Our mission: Working together to help locate the missing, name the unidentified
    and discuss true crime cases within an intellectual, safe and respectful Internet community.
    *~*~*~*Don't forget, we are on Facebook! www.facebook.com/CrimeWatchersNet*~*~*~*~*
    CLICK HERE FOR FORUM SUPPORT
    Dismiss Notice
Dismiss Notice
Welcome to Crimewatchers.net! We are happy to have you with us.
Please let any staff member know if you need assistance. We're here to help! (If you aren't a member, please join us today. We'd love to meet you!)
Dismiss Notice
Crimewatchers.net opened on April 26, 2015 with the purpose of making a difference in getting the word out for the missing, unidentified, and justice for victims. Let us know if you have a case you'd like us to feature here, on Twitter &/or Facebook. Contact email: CrimewatchersCW@gmail.com

AUSTRALIA TAMAM SHUD CASE: W/M, 40-50, found on Somerton Beach, Adelaide - 1 Dec 1948

Discussion in 'Australia: Missing & Unidentified' started by Dobrev, Dec 5, 2018.

  1. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

    The Tamam Shud case, also known as the Mystery of the Somerton Man:


    The Tamam Shud case, also known as the Mystery of the Somerton Man, is an unsolved case of an unidentified man found dead at 6:30 am, 1 December 1948, on Somerton beach, Glenelg, just south of Adelaide, South Australia. It is named after the Persian phrase tamám shud, meaning "ended" or "finished", printed on a scrap of paper found months later in the fob pocket of the man's trousers. The scrap had been torn from the final page of a copy of Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam, authored by 12th-century poet Omar Khayyám. Tamam was misspelt as Taman in many early reports and this error has often been repeated, leading to confusion about the name in the media.

    220px-SomertonMan2.jpg

    A coronial inquest found a roll of paper hidden in a secret pocket in the man’s clothing.

    On it was printed Tamam Shud, or “finished” in Persian. It was torn from a book of Persian poetry — the Rubáiyát of Omar Khayyáma. A Glenelg doctor found the book thrown through the open window of his car.

    When the back page of the book was treated with iodine during a coronial inquest, five lines of code appeared — letters that have mystified police, code-breakers and amateur sleuths the world and internet over.

    The phone number of a local nurse, Jo Thomson, was found in the book. Her home was five minutes’ walk from where he was found dead.

    Ms Thomson identified the body as one Alf Boxall, to whom she said she had given a copy of the Rubáiyát.

    But Alf Boxall came forward, alive and with his copy of the Rubáiyát intact.

    Mr Cramer, who lived in Adelaide from 1977 until 1990 and now lives on the Sunshine Coast, said a line of the micro-writing appears to refer to a British post-war jet.

    Professor Abbott is urging the State Government to exhume the Somerton Man, to solve one of the other big mysteries — whether or not he and Jo Thompson had a child together.

    In January, the family of the nurse, who died in 2007, told 60 Minutes she may have been a spy and had a son with the Somerton Man.

    www.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tamam_Shud_case

    https://www.adelaidenow.com.au/news...d/news-story/3951eef52092ee56916aeefbc1b7007b
     
    Paradise, Whatsnext and Kimster like this.
  2. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

    3.png 2.png 1.png

    Pictures of the "Taman Shud" reference that was ripped out of the poetry booked.
    The book ripped.
    And the writing investigators are trying to decipher.

    The man died on the beach with his feet crossed, with no signs of struggle or distress to mark his end. Passersby had mistaken him for a drunk. The labels had been clipped from his clothing. His pockets held chewing gum, combs, and unused bus and train tickets.

    An autopsy failed to find a cause of death, and noted that the man was in his forties with a fit physique. (A coroner’s assistant said the man possessed strong and high calf muscles.) The coroner suspected that the man had been poisoned or killed himself, but couldn’t find any evidence for this theory.

    Investigators did find one bizarre clue: a scrap of paper tucked in the man’s watch pocket, printed with the words “Tamám Shud,” which means “finished” in Persian. The scrap came from the last words of the last page of The Rubáiyát of Omar Khayyam, an 11th-century poetry book about life’s transience.

    Police recovered the man’s suitcase from the train station (a spool of thread inside the case matched the thread used to repair one of the man’s pockets), yielding more incomplete clues. It held only a few tools, a shaving kit, and clothes, including a coat with feather stitching that bespoke US tailoring. It also held Wrigley’s Juicy Fruit gum, which American men chewed back then, but Australian men didn’t. The Australian police consulted FBI chief J. Edgar Hoover, but the agency couldn’t find a fingerprint match of the man.

    The Cold War was on, leading some journalists to later speculate that the Somerton Man was a murdered spy, either American or Russian.

    https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/danvergano/who-is-the-somerton-man#.chaWkLjYY
     
    Paradise and Kimster like this.
  3. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

    Chasing another avenue, Abbott turned back to the copy of The Rubáiyát that had been found in the car, which had a phone number scrawled on its back cover. At the time, the number belonged to a 27-year-old local woman named Jo Thomson. When police originally contacted her, she denied knowing the dead man. And she remained coyabout the man’s identity, despite decades of speculation, until her death in 2007.

    Abbott started asking her family about the case. She had a son, Robin, born in 1946, who had two distinctive facial features — an oddly shaped ear, and two missing incisors that left his canine teeth parked right next to his two front teeth — that Abbott learned were shared by the Somerton Man. Robin Thomson was also a dancer in the Australian Ballet, blessed with strong calves. All of those things, Abbott thought, pointed to Robin as the son of the Somerton Man.

    Robin Thomson died in 2009, but he was survived by his ex-wife, Roma Egan, and a daughter, Rachel. Abbott wrote a letter to Roma, asking if she knew anyone who resembled the Somerton Man. Yes, she replied: her ex-husband. Abbott went to see her and convinced her of the genetic link, which is how Fitzpatrick, the DNA genealogist, entered the investigation.

    Abbott had heard of Fitzpatrick’s work tracking down people’s relatives, including a boy who died on the Titanicand a Colorado man living with amnesia in search of his family.

    If Rachel is the granddaughter of the Somerton Man, then she inherited about 25% of his DNA. Fitzpatrick compared DNA from Rachel and her mother to identify which portions of her genome came from her father. Then the scientist ran those segments through massive DNA databases (maintained by genealogy companies such as Ancestry.com) to try to find out more about her father’s father — the suspected Somerton Man.

    As Fitzpatrick will present at next week’s meeting, Rachel’s paternal line traced back to the Mid-Atlantic states of the US, centered around Virginia.

    “We see traces of Native American ancestry and chromosomes linked to relatives of Thomas Jefferson,” Fitzpatrick said. The Native American genes tied to the Somerton Man also come from tribes living along the East Coast, she said. “That puts Mr. X’s ancestry, with some authority, in America.”

    https://www.buzzfeednews.com/article/danvergano/who-is-the-somerton-man#.chaWkLjYY
     
    Paradise, Whatsnext and Kimster like this.
  4. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

  5. Kimster

    Kimster Director Staff Member

    What an interesting story! I'm anxious to see how the DNA analysis sorts out. I definitely believe he was an American.
     
    Paradise likes this.
  6. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

    Me too! I get so drawn into these odd cases, then it annoys me that we don't know the answer lol.

    I'm assuming that Robin is his son. The connection between the UID and Robin's mother seems the most logical.
     
    Paradise and Kimster like this.
  7. Kimster

    Kimster Director Staff Member

    I wonder why Robin's mum was so evasive about it?
     
    Paradise and Dobrev like this.
  8. Dobrev

    Dobrev Former Member

    She was unmarried and had previously lied about being married (to Alf, the guy she says she gave the book too) which of course, was frowned upon in the 40's. She was also in a relationship with a new guy, who she planned to marry once his divorce went through. So, it is my opinion that she kept it a secret to not be looked down on, and to also have her child believe her now husband was his father.

    All of this could be wrong, that's just my opinion.
     
    Paradise and Kimster like this.
  9. Kimster

    Kimster Director Staff Member

    I forgot about the times of the day. She probably was trying to save her reputation, and Robin's!
     
    Dobrev and Paradise like this.
  10. peteb

    peteb New Member

    As in any unresolved mystery, the more research done sometimes results in an ever bigger mystery - and sometimes theorists become a little entangled with the facts or don't have a full grasp of the details. So, rather than put a Somerton Man theory forward I've posed what I think are the questions that need answering before theorising begins.

    You might need a cup of coffee to get through them all ..

    Why did Jessica Harkness tell the police everything she knew about Alfred Boxall yet nothing of the Somerton Man .. ?

    Why didn’t Harkness tell the police anything about the Somerton Man .. ?

    Why was she shocked to see his likeness .. ?

    Why wasn’t she categorised as a Person of Interest .. ?

    Why wasn’t there a follow up interview .. ?

    Why wasn’t Sir Cedric Stanton Hicks, Professor of Physiology and Pharmacology, asked for an opinion on the condition of his feet .. ?

    Why was it left to Paul Lawson, Taxidermist .. ?

    Why were there no socks in his luggage when he carried spare ties, shirts, trousers, underpants, singlets, coat, shirt, comb … ?

    Why wasn’t Harkness asked by Feltus if her pet name was Jestyn .. ?

    Why was a box of Bryant and May matches later included in his possessions .. ?

    Why wasn’t Harkness asked by Feltus if she knew a man named Keane .. ?

    Why were two tickets left in his pocket when everything else that identified him was taken .. ?

    Why did these tickets lead back to the train station and the suitcase .. ?

    Why didn’t the police pursue this line of enquiry .. ?

    Why did they wait for Detective Brown to issue a general enquiry about missing luggage before the police visited the train station luggage office .. ?

    Why wasn’t anyone seen lying by the Childrens Home steps before 7:30 pm or after 8:30 pm on the night of November 30th .. ?

    Why has SA Major Crimes taken possession of the previously authorised DNA samples legally obtained by analyst Blackie .. ?

    Why, considering they took them over seventeen months ago, did it take so long for the seizure to be publicly known .. ?

    Why was Gordon Strapp’s Deposition ignored when it would have effected the inquest outcome .. ?

    Why do we take for granted that Littlemore’s question to Boxall about involvement in Intelligence related to his service with the Nackeroos .. ?

    Why do we believe the Nackeroos were involved in Intelligence when they were a commando style unit .. ?

    Why then did Boxall admit working with Intelligence .. ?

    Why didn’t Stuart Littlemore ask Boxall if he knew a man named Keane .. ?

    Why didn’t Littlemore ask Boxall if he knew Harkness as Jestyn .. ?

    Why was the identity of Chemist Freeman withheld for seventy years .. ?

    Why did the lividity on his upper body contradict the position his body was found in .. ?

    Why did Harkness, a young single woman, give Boxall, an older married man, a copy of theRubaiyat prior to his overseas posting .. ?

    Why didn’t Boxall’s wife give him a copy of the Rubaiyat prior to his overseas posting .. ?

    Why would Harkness inscribe Boxall Verse 70 when her relationship with him was only occasional .. ?

    Why did he have Kensitas cigarettes in an Army Club packet .. ?

    Why was a handkerchief, singlet and a pair of jockey underpants added to his possessions .. ?

    Why wasn’t Harkness asked if she had any digitalis in the house .. ?

    Why wasn’t Prosper Thomson asked if he took digitalis for his haemoptysis .. ?

    Why didn’t the police pursue this line of enquiry .. ?

    Why was a half-smoked cigarette found on the body when he didn’t have the means to light it .. ?

    Why didn’t Stuart Littlemore ask Boxall if Harkness wrote the inscription .. ?

    Why weren’t the airlines checked for arrivals on or about November 30th .. ?

    Why wasn’t the Rubaiyat handed in before the inquest .. ?

    Why has the code defied generations of code-breakers .. ?

    Why were his feet ‘wedge shaped’ .. ?

    Why didn’t the ABC interviewer ask Kate Thomson if her mother’s pet name was Jestyn .. ?

    Why was the cigarette found on the body not retained as evidence .. ?

    Why was there no correspondence in his suitcase when he had enough envelopes to suggest he wrote regularly .. ?

    Why don’t we know who marked up the code .. ?

    Why was the code marked up .. ?

    ~~



    Why were there no scorch marks on his skin or clothing given he had a partly smoked cigarette wedged under his chin .. ?

    Why did he have such an exceptional physique .. ?

    Why didn’t the police take note of the number of second-hand, already inscribed Rubaiyats on the used book market .. ?



    Why wasn’t Jessica Harkness interviewed, for the record .. ?



    Why did Leane’s Deposition include a box of Bryant and May matches when his initial listing of possessions didn’t .. ?



    Why did Leane’s Deposition differ from Moss’ in regard to the box of Bryant and May matches .. ?

    Why did it take so long for the police to find out what Tamam Shud meant, seeing as the Rubaiyat was very popular in Australia .. ?



    Why was he stripped of all his identity .. ?



    Why are we accepting that Jessica was nicknamed Jestyn .. ?

    Why didn’t Feltus ask Harkness if she was known as Jestyn .. ?

    Why are we accepting that the man seen the night before was the same man seen in the morning .. ?

    Why were there abrasions on the knuckles of his right hand .. ?

    ~~

    Why would the police have thought a ship’s 3rd Officer would improvise his own tools .. ?

    Why did he have cigarettes and no matches .. ?

    Why has the witness statement that tells of a man carrying a man along the foreshore on the night of the 30th been withheld .. ?

    Why was the only officially released image of the code marked up .. ?

    Why isn’t there a photo of the unmarked code .. ?

    Why has SA Major Crimes held the DNA samples for over seventeen months .. ?

    Why was Senior Government Analyst Cowan unable to identify a black powder shaken from a brush that was part of a homemade set of tools taken from the man’s luggage .. ?

    Why does the thought occur that the man has already been identified by SA Major Crimes through their analysing of the samples taken from analyst Blackie .. ?

    And finally,

    .. why does the thought occur that the any official findings of the DNA samples will be suppressed .. ?

    More here: https://tomsbytwo.com

    Question everything .. and thanks for getting this far
     
    Last edited: Oct 12, 2019

Share This Page