It's beginning to be too frustrating for me to discuss because you obviously haven't watched the video.
I don't understand why you hold it against her that she appeared with a lawyer?
There was never a time- including then- that she hadn't answered every question- many multiple times- she was asked, which bore out to true to the best of her knowledge and/or belief.
Indeed, along the way, she'd had questions for them, which for me, there were times where it was hard to tell whether they were telling her the truth of what they believed!
I'm sure I've heard only audio of that interview. In fact, the only interview with both audio and video that I'm aware of that's been released is that last one, on March 1.
As I've pointed out, it was very shortly after that "interview" that Madeline's body was found.
I've read in a report that she was informed, began to cry, and handed the phone over to her father (I think it was).
Info from the friend as I heard it is that there wasn't any panic, just a comment that she hadn't had hers yet.
As for JS tracking her period, there are plenty of good reasons to do that other than what ever you must be thinking.
Yeah, I agree, I thnk it could have been any of those reasons.
You know, Madeline's crush was something new, I wonder whether that somehow had anything to do with it.
Info re that Telegram chatroom- that people have been blackmailed into doing all sorts of horrific things- and that he was on that site that very night is very disturbing and I also wonder whether that has anything to do with anything...
Yes, I do believe the parent's info that he was anxious and stressed. Now, something's up with that, I just don't know what, but it does seem to me that it's likely related to her murder.
I am going to go by paragraphs.
First, what video have I not watched? The only one in which she was on video (other than news?) because I did. If we are talking of different ones, let me know. More than willing to watch.
Second, I don't hold it against her. And I have not convicted her. On anything yet. I am just not at square one with her any longer. And she has admitted to a lie or two with very poor excuses. And she needed a rule about overnights with Stephan. I don't understand why out of tons of things and a mom sending her to the same bed with how old of a man when she's 13 doesn't phase you. And I mean that of course not to offend but nothing in this whole case regarding her decisions even give you a blip of thinking she wasn't making at minimum the wisest of decisions and I guess I don't understand that?
Third, I could well be mixing up interviews as to what was said in which. Easily can admit that. So the one she was on video and audio, was that the one with her attorney? I'd hope you'd understand you said yourself not long ago that you were losing the details on SS because we'd been discussing JS, it's been a LOT of info dump, a lot to watch, listen to, etc.
Paragraph four of yours. yes, I heard that too. it didn't last long. I'm open on that one as to my opinion...
Number five. MS didn't share even being SAed by her mom's "bf" and perhaps did think they were in love, who the HE77 knows what he had her convinced of. Maybe she wanted to be pg in a very juvenile naive and barely teenaged way. Or she is hiding any panic just as she hid the SA or what she may have believed to be, groomed by him, a relationship. Part two of that paragraph, I'm not saying there isn't good reason for her to track the period so much as I'm saying if she was so diligent in doing that, THAT month she apparently did not, did not notice, etc...
Your ending. We can agree on that re his possible reasons then. And the crush, I'd agree and add as a possibility. But even if SS did this over a crush, it was still related to her probably saying I'm done, I have a crush on a boy, I am going to tell, you need to stop. And/or he knew the control over her was ending and he was at risk as she was about to move on or thinking she was going to.
Finally your last sentence. Not so sure about depressed but yes, that day he was anxious and panicked is more like it sounded. And even though we have to take whatever from whoever as it is their view or statements and not evidence, this is one statement both you and I believe from the parents (mostly dad) that he was like a tinder box they were scared to set off that day, asking if they had was it anxiety meds or anything he could take etc.? I think he definitely was panicked over something re MS and knew he was going to have no choice (in his mind) but to kill her. It does sound like we agree basically on this one.
Tell me, just so I can try to get it better, how you rate JS as a mom in general... And based on what? I mean she never even put a roof over her child's head to speak of herself. And I don't buy or fall into using mental health excuses re a lot of things. So if that's a reason, let's not go there. JS is NOT in her 20s. Her child is THIRTEEN. Or sadly was.
Just trying to understand how you don't see that she was far from a stellar mom. If we are all honest, none of us ever feel we couldn't do better but she failed miserably. She's, and so is he, sadly representative of a generation, that's all about me, and my issues, and my mental health, etc. Thankfully not all of that generation turned into such.
I'm not saying she may not be bipolar, etc. but where is it she is ever on an even keel and doing a good job?
We have Mel in here now and I'd say she'd have a lot to say about such used as excuses.
Let me put it more clearly-- do you see anything in JS she could have done better, as most of us always can? I think what I have trouble with is I almost think you see her as perfect and we know she isn't by a long shot. That's where I fall down I think.. If you just think she did the best she could and was a product of a bad childhood herself, or naive, then even though I wouldn't find that an excuse, at least I'd realize you don't see her as some perfect mom. Because she sure the heck wasn't. None of us are. But boy she truly was not.
And again, please keep in mind I have not convicted her but I sure can't be on square one any longer where she is concerned. Most out there HAVE convicted her. And there's plenty of reason and ammo she gave them for that as well.
We do agree on him it seems and that there was a catalyst that had this murder intended he was panicked about the day before...
More on your ending. That's interesting and may play in at some point re Telegram.