Champlain Towers South in Surfside, Miami-Dade, FL collapsed 2021 June 24

1695698088024.png
“As I moved closer, I could hear somebody making noise and yelling. I started to get close to the building and climbed into the debris, and I could hear him saying that he was over there, and I could see his arm sticking up through the debris and waving his hand,” Nicholas Balboa, a man from Phoenix, told CNBC’s “The News with Shepard Smith” on Thursday night.

“He was just saying, ‘Please don’t leave me, please don’t leave me.’ I told him that we weren’t going to leave him,” Balboa said. “It was myself and one other person. So, we were there and we just felt like we could get to him. It didn’t feel right to just leave him, especially hearing that his voice was just so young.”

Balboa was in Surfside, Florida, to visit his father when Champlain Towers South building crumbled early Thursday. According to NBC News, authorities were called about the collapse around 1:30 a.m. ET

 
Last edited by a moderator:

Feud between mayors: Surfside pushes for access to site of building collapse; Miami-Dade keeps denying it​

Recent letters between Miami-Dade Mayor Daniella Levine Cava and Surfside Mayor Charles Burkett show there has been tension behind the scenes in the aftermath of the June 24th building collapse that killed 98 people.

Both mayors share the desire to want to keep residents in the area safe, but they have a disagreement about who should be conducting what investigation and when. Trouble is Surfside officials may be suspects in the initial investigation into what caused a section of the 12-story Champlain Towers South to turn into a compact mountain of pancaked concrete.

Miami-Dade detectives and prosecutors and the National Institute of Standards and Technology are conducting the initial investigation into the cause of the tragedy. Surfside hired Allyn Kilsheimer, of KCE Structural Engineers, to look for safety issues related to Champlain Towers North, which was built by the same developer and in the same year as Champlain South.

“If we are denied the ability to access the site, a property within our own municipality, and we cannot do the investigations that our expert has prescribed because of the County’s refusal to give us set access, then the County, must assume full and complete responsibility for any loss of life and any other damages that may result,” Burkett wrote to Levine Cava on July 23rd.

Burkett sent the letter three days after the search-and-recovery crews found the remains of the 98th victim. Levine Cava responded nearly a week later. There was frustration in their exchange, but Levine Cava wrote Kilsheimer is being heard and will have access to preliminary reports on the ongoing probe.
 
“Flawed from day one” reads the report, which highlights problems in the original plans that forced the builders to make decisions on the fly that would have compromised the structure. Drawn up by a firm — Breiterman, Jurado and Associates — that no longer exists, the plans specified structural columns that were too narrow to accommodate enough rebar, meaning that contractors had to choose between cramming extra steel into a too-small column — which can create air pockets that accelerate corrosion — or inadequately attaching floor slabs to their supports. Both theories were proposed by experts who questioned the structural integrity of the building immediately after the collapse. Some of the most problematic areas of the structure were around the pool deck, where a video recorded by a tourist staying across the street shows water pouring into the parking garage underneath minutes before the collapse.
 
“Flawed from day one” reads the report, which highlights problems in the original plans that forced the builders to make decisions on the fly that would have compromised the structure. Drawn up by a firm — Breiterman, Jurado and Associates — that no longer exists, the plans specified structural columns that were too narrow to accommodate enough rebar, meaning that contractors had to choose between cramming extra steel into a too-small column — which can create air pockets that accelerate corrosion — or inadequately attaching floor slabs to their supports. Both theories were proposed by experts who questioned the structural integrity of the building immediately after the collapse. Some of the most problematic areas of the structure were around the pool deck, where a video recorded by a tourist staying across the street shows water pouring into the parking garage underneath minutes before the collapse.
So I assume that the plans had to be taken in for consideration for the actual building permit. Who was the one (or many) that dropped the ball on this? Being able to read those plans and knowing that those columns were drawn too small for the building should have been one of the first things they noticed and forced a new plan before issuing the permit.

This smells of incompetence and/or $$$$$.
 
The town has already received an offer on the property, but what the future holds for this land is in limbo.

Some families want to see a memorial where the Champlain Towers South once stood, but a bid of up to $120 million is on the table from a private developer.

There are very few details on who the bidder might be, or their intention for the property if the purchase goes through.

Money from the sale would likely be used to compensate victims, as dozens of lawsuits hang in the balance.

 
Angela Gonzalez's mother, Kathleen Gonzalez, told NBC News in July that paramedics told her "they should not be alive" after what they went through.

Deven, a high school volleyball player, fell with the building and suffered a crushed leg and snapped femur, and a piece of metal pierced her skull. Her recovery could take two years.

Angela Gonzalez, who had a collapsed lung and smashed pelvis, was in a coma for five days, woke up on her birthday to find out her husband, Edgar, was among those unaccounted for. His name was later added to the list of 98 people who were killed in the collapse.

"He was my best friend," Angela Gonzalez said. "He was my person."
 

'I'm shocked by this result': Tentative $997M settlement announced in Florida condo collapse​

A nearly $1 billion tentative settlement has been reached in a class-action lawsuit brought by families of victims and survivors of last June's condominium collapse in Surfside, Florida, an attorney said Wednesday.

Harley S. Tropin announced the $997 million settlement during a hearing before Miami-Dade Circuit Court Judge Michael Hanzman. Still pending final approval, the settlement involves insurance companies, developers of an adjacent building and other defendants.

“I’m shocked by this result — I think it’s fantastic,” Hanzman said. “This is a recovery that is far in excess of what I had anticipated.”
 

Probe of Florida building collapse that killed 98 to be completed by June 2025, US investigators say​

The probe into the 2021 collapse of a beachfront condominium building that killed 98 people in South Florida should be completed by the fourth anniversary of the disaster, federal officials said Thursday.

The investigation led by the National Institute of Standards & Technology is looking into two dozen different scenarios that could explain why the 12-story Champlain Towers South building in Surfside, Florida, abruptly failed early in the morning of June 24, 2021, they said. Surfside is a suburb north of Miami.

“We’re still not prepared to close the door on any of them yet,” said Glenn Bell, associate team lead of the Champlain Towers probe. “We are still testing, testing, testing.”

Much attention has focused on the pool deck, which investigators previously said failed to comply with the original building codes and standards, with many areas of severe strength deficiency that likely contributed to the disaster. Officials said Thursday the pool area remains a central focus, along with the garage beneath it.

“The interaction of the pool deck and the tower is really important in the progression of the collapse,” Bell said.

There also were studies done on the ground underneath the building to determine whether sinkholes, underground voids or soil irregularities might have played a role. Investigators have not found evidence that was a factor.

Judith Mitrani-Reiser, the Champlain Towers investigative team lead, said 24 computer hard drives have been recovered that might have video or other evidence that could help explain what happened. Photos were shown at Thursday’s meeting of a seventh-floor unit where a video camera on a table captured some debris falling from above before the building collapsed.

That kind of evidence is invaluable, she said.

“The information from the public has been just an amazing asset to our investigation,” Mitrani-Reiser said. “A different angle would really be tremendous. We are really at the mercy of what we can find.”
 
20255555??? Wow way to get after it. I know, I know, there are reasons. It's complex. Have to cover the right butts because of litigation etc.
 

Setbacks in federal investigation delay answers in Champlain Towers collapse by another year​

Families of the 98 people who died in the collapse of Champlain Towers South in June 2021 found out Thursday they will now have to wait at least another 19 months for answers from the federal government as to what caused the disaster.

Investigators with the National Institute of Standards and Technology announced the “unfortunate” 11-month delay from their previous schedule during an overview and update they provided to the National Construction Safety Team Advisory Committee outside Washington, DC.


After spending $32.6 million over more than three years, NIST said “difficulties and setbacks” require them to add nearly a year to their schedule before a report will be issued for public consumption in April 2026 – and that assumes no more problems or “surprises.”

“Unfortunately, we have faced technical and programmatic delays that have caused us to adjust our timeline,” said lead investigator Judith Mitrani-Reiser. “We will issue our report for public comment as soon as the science permits, and we will continue keeping communities in Surfside and Miami-Dade County informed of our progress.”


Glenn Bell, the associate lead investigator, detailed some “challenges” causing the delay, but withheld certain information discovered in the testing of columns that has altered the team’s view of their role in the failure, saying it was premature to announce that publicly.

He did cite difficulties their testing contractor has had trying to replicate the slab-column connections that existed when the pool deck collapsed, followed minutes later by most of the condominium’s units tumbling or pancaking onto lower levels.

They were unable to produce “specimens that are replicas as close as possible to what existed at CTS,” Bell said, citing problems duplicating the concrete strength, dimensions, tolerances and flatness. Plus there were “challenges with mixing and placing that led to some consolidation problems,” Bell said.

“The CTS program has had difficulties and setbacks,” Bell said, noting its testing contractor had to bring in extra help. “We’ve had to pause on occasions to reflect on the challenges, and to take corrective actions, bring in new expertise, modify our processes, but we’re on track now.”

“As we peel back more layers of the onion, new realizations appear that must be pursued,” Bell said, citing “surprises” such as a sample of concrete from a piling that could withstand only 1,700 pounds per square inch (PSI) of load, far below the minimum standard of 3,000 PSI.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,074
Messages
254,848
Members
1,014
Latest member
SaraPlum
Back
Top Bottom