SD SERENITY DENNARD: Missing from Pennington County, SD - 3 February 2019 - Age 9

1698454337028.png

Serenity was 9 on Feb. 3, 2019, when she ran away on a cold Sunday morning from the Black Hills Children’s Home, a residential youth treatment facility located near Rockerville in Pennington County, amid some of the most rugged and remote terrain in all of South Dakota.

Though witnesses saw her run off, and a search began almost immediately, Serenity has never been seen again and no evidence of her death has been discovered.

edited by staff to add media link
 
Last edited:
They were back out again this weekend, through Tuesday.


Seven canine teams to join search for missing persons in Pennington County

Seven teams from Colorado Forensic Canines and Tri-State Canines are planning a four-day search for two long-missing persons in Pennington County. Teams from Colorado, Montana and Wyoming will arrive on Friday, May 15, and will search Saturday through Tuesday. The Pennington County Sheriff’s Office, Pennington County Search and Rescue and Rockerville Volunteer Fire Department will provide some support personnel.
It is nice to know they are still searching. This little girl has a piece of my heart.
 
Serenity had reactive attachment disorder (RAD) and disruptive mood dysregulation disorder (DMDD)

"Reactive attachment disorder is a condition in which your child is unable to establish healthy attachment with you, their parent or primary caretaker. This can lead to difficulty connecting with others and managing their emotions, resulting in a lack of trust and self-worth, a fear of getting close to anyone, anger, and a need to be in control. A child with an attachment disorder feels unsafe and alone".
✂️
"RAD and other attachment disorders occur when a child has been unable to consistently connect with a parent or primary caregiver.
If a young child repeatedly feels abandoned, isolated, powerless, or uncared for—whatever the reason—they will learn that they can’t depend on others and that the world is a dangerous and frightening place.
This can happen for many reasons:
  • A baby cries and no one responds or offers comfort.
  • A baby is hungry or wet, and they aren’t attended to for hours.
  • No one looks at, talks to, or smiles at the baby, so the baby feels alone.
  • A young child gets attention only by acting out or displaying other extreme behaviors.
  • A young child or baby is mistreated or abused.
  • Sometimes the child’s needs are met and sometimes they aren’t. The child never knows what to expect.
  • The infant or young child is hospitalized or separated from their parents.
  • A baby or young child is moved from one caregiver to another (the result of adoption, foster care, or the loss of a parent, for example).
  • The parent is emotionally unavailable because of depression, illness, or substance abuse."

 
On Wednesday February 6, the Sheriff requested special dog teams from Iowa, Wyoming and Colorado. The dogs were trained to located deceased persons. These dogs find it hard to detect scent in frigid conditions.

1SearchMap.jpg

This map shows lines where people and dogs have searched for Serenity Dennard in the area around the Black Hills Children’s Home south of Rockerville. The lines, recorded by GPS devices, are blue in places where people have searched and red in spots where people and dogs have searched together. The hand of Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom is pointing to where Serenity Dennard was last seen, about 50 yards north of the entrance to the children’s home.

Snip*

As of August 2019, the Sheriff’s office had chased 195 leads in 15 states, conducted 440 interviews and executed six search warrants.

In November 2019, online footage of a young child was captured on a Ring doorbell in Harriet Creek Ranch, Texas. The child appeared to be begging for help and many people suggested that the child bore resemblance to Serenity. Serenity’s family viewed the footage and said that it was not their child.

img_6805.jpg

February 3, 2020, marks the one-year anniversary of Serenity’s disappearance. Despite a search involving over 1,200 people and 4,500 miles of woods being searched, no trace of her has been found. The working theory for Law Enforcement is that Serenity ran into the woods, got lost and died from hypothermia.

Since her disappearance, the Black Hills Children’s Home has been cited by state and federal regulators for waiting 80 minutes to call 911, for having radios that were on different channels and for lacking planning and training in runaway prevention.

Two people with direct physical charge of Serenity at the time of her disappearance were fired after she ran away, according to Children’s Home Society Executive Director Michelle Lavallee. But the on-call supervisor who advised employees on the scene to search longer on their own before calling 911 remains employed, as does the director of the home.

Deputy Jamin Hartland, the Pennington County Sheriff’s Office lead detective on the case, said the investigation is the most extensive in Pennington County history, and so far has shown no evidence of an abduction or other form of foul play.
Snip*

 
On Wednesday February 6, the Sheriff requested special dog teams from Iowa, Wyoming and Colorado. The dogs were trained to located deceased persons. These dogs find it hard to detect scent in frigid conditions.

1SearchMap.jpg

This map shows lines where people and dogs have searched for Serenity Dennard in the area around the Black Hills Children’s Home south of Rockerville. The lines, recorded by GPS devices, are blue in places where people have searched and red in spots where people and dogs have searched together. The hand of Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom is pointing to where Serenity Dennard was last seen, about 50 yards north of the entrance to the children’s home.

Snip*

As of August 2019, the Sheriff’s office had chased 195 leads in 15 states, conducted 440 interviews and executed six search warrants.

In November 2019, online footage of a young child was captured on a Ring doorbell in Harriet Creek Ranch, Texas. The child appeared to be begging for help and many people suggested that the child bore resemblance to Serenity. Serenity’s family viewed the footage and said that it was not their child.

img_6805.jpg

February 3, 2020, marks the one-year anniversary of Serenity’s disappearance. Despite a search involving over 1,200 people and 4,500 miles of woods being searched, no trace of her has been found. The working theory for Law Enforcement is that Serenity ran into the woods, got lost and died from hypothermia.

Since her disappearance, the Black Hills Children’s Home has been cited by state and federal regulators for waiting 80 minutes to call 911, for having radios that were on different channels and for lacking planning and training in runaway prevention.

Two people with direct physical charge of Serenity at the time of her disappearance were fired after she ran away, according to Children’s Home Society Executive Director Michelle Lavallee. But the on-call supervisor who advised employees on the scene to search longer on their own before calling 911 remains employed, as does the director of the home.

Deputy Jamin Hartland, the Pennington County Sheriff’s Office lead detective on the case, said the investigation is the most extensive in Pennington County history, and so far has shown no evidence of an abduction or other form of foul play.
Snip*

Now I'm wondering, who was this little girl caught on the door cam??
 

A missing girl and hunter were not found during a four-day search in rural areas of Pennington County.

Pennington County and other South Dakota and out-of-state agencies have covered 5,559 miles while searching for Dennard since she went missing.

The four-day search began Saturday and continued through Tuesday. It involved seven teams from Colorado Forensic Canines and Tri-State Canines who live in Colorado, Montana and Wyoming. The Rockerville Fire Department, Pennington County Sheriff’s Office and Pennington County Search and Rescue also provide support personnel.

The volunteers and dogs searched by foot and on side-by-sides and with the SHERP all-terrain vehicle, according to Helene Duhamel, spokeswoman for the sheriff’s office. The teams covered 190 miles in the area Genzlinger went missing and 110 miles for Dennard.

The sheriff’s office is not sharing specifics of the search, Duhamel said when asked if the dogs picked up any scents or found any evidence such as clothing.
 
A bump for you Serenity...

You crossed my mind today and a few times recently more than even the norm. I don't know what happened to you but a case or two recently remind me of yours. Of all cases, Vanessa Guillen's is one. Throw a subordinate or two under the bus and never fix a bigger problem. In your case, a couple of employees got fired, the home got a look over and recommendations but the big money head maintains his job and he was the one who flat out lied right on camera about when 911 was called... The big $$$ in that huge nonprofit and big salaries but they can't afford cameras or decently paid qualified trained help... Cynical day here...

The other comparison? Some may not agree but with both you and with Guillen they expected no one to care and it just to go away... The public kept it alive, the internet kept it alive, in her case, the family kept it alive...

Oh and one of the largest military installations in our country cannot afford cameras... Huh...

Someone, someone, probably in the sheriff's department or home made sure someone found out about the lie about the 911 call and time that the big guy said on the news cameras... For you Serenity. Someone did that. I often wonder who...

You may have ran and died from exposure, hard to say. We may never know. I for one am not sold on that and if you did, I am not sold on why... Nor the lead up and reasons nor response...

One thing is for sure.... That home is nowhere secure and safe for a child with any issues which is what it is supposed to be... And the reason for its existence...

Smh. RIP child.
 
The Vanished podcast about Serenity. LOTS of good information. It's almost an hour and a half long but worth the listen, IMO. Not really anything "new", but still good. Gives really good info on Reactive Attachment Disorder and Oppositional Defiant Disorder and what Serenity would have been dealing with. (She was actually bounced around from 12-13 foster homes in a 2 year period, which would help explain why she may have developed those disorders.) Talks with some of her bio family and her adoptive father.


1596581516256.png 1596581524476.png 1596581529778.png 1596581542819.png
 
Family of Serenity Dennard hires a private investigator to investigate her disappearance

The family of Serenity Dennard has hired a private investigative the disappearance of the missing Sturgis girl.

Then 8-eight-years old, Serenity Dennard went missing from the Black Hills Children’s Home near Rockerville on February 3rd, 2019. Multiple search efforts to locate the missing girl have been, thus far, unsuccessful. In a Facebook post today, Carmel, Indiana-based investigative firm Veracity I-I-R confirmed that they were hired by Serenity’s family to investigate her disappearance.


 
Family of Serenity Dennard hires a private investigator to investigate her disappearance

The family of Serenity Dennard has hired a private investigative the disappearance of the missing Sturgis girl.

Then 8-eight-years old, Serenity Dennard went missing from the Black Hills Children’s Home near Rockerville on February 3rd, 2019. Multiple search efforts to locate the missing girl have been, thus far, unsuccessful. In a Facebook post today, Carmel, Indiana-based investigative firm Veracity I-I-R confirmed that they were hired by Serenity’s family to investigate her disappearance.



I hope the PI finds something!
 
Family of Serenity Dennard hires a private investigator to investigate her disappearance

The family of Serenity Dennard has hired a private investigative the disappearance of the missing Sturgis girl.

Then 8-eight-years old, Serenity Dennard went missing from the Black Hills Children’s Home near Rockerville on February 3rd, 2019. Multiple search efforts to locate the missing girl have been, thus far, unsuccessful. In a Facebook post today, Carmel, Indiana-based investigative firm Veracity I-I-R confirmed that they were hired by Serenity’s family to investigate her disappearance.



I don't know what to make of this. While all the help in any case is great, most people seem to accept that she ran off and died in the woods so I don't know what they could investigate that would help find her.

On the other hand, I am one that has never entirely bought into that and there is much to question on how she went missing, why she was not under a one on one etc. I do not think though that answers to any of those questions or any questions would find her so again, what are they looking for?

I think there is likely another reason for the investigation and will leave it at that jmo. Time will tell I guess.

Edited to fix more than a few typos.
 
Last edited:
They do have a witness that was driving into the ranch that saw her standing out by the gate. I think the biggest question is... was she waiting for someone specific? Did she happen to catch a ride from someone coming or going that never came forward? Was she just standing there getting up the nerve to keep going or expecting someone to come after her (trying to make a scene?)? Did she decide to go on foot when she couldn't get a ride? I do think these are all important to consider, and stuff the investigators probably have already looked into (and I'm sure the PI will look into further). But still most likely, IMO, is that she is out there in the woods somewhere. But as always, gotta look at every possibility.
 
A little recap and a bit more on the PI.

Serenity Dennard: Missing 9-Year-Old’s Family Hires Retired FBI to Find Her

Serenity Dennard is a 9-year-old South Dakota girl who disappeared on February 3, 2019, and was the subject of one of the most extensive missing persons searches in the state’s history.

This week, her adoptive parents, Chad Dennard and Darcie Gentry, have revived the search, hiring a private investigation firm made up of FBI and police veterans in hope of finally tracking their daughter down.

Doug Kouns, a retired FBI agent with Veracity IIR, the Indiana-based firm hired by Serenity’s parents, gave Heavy an overview of his strategy in the fresh search for the girl on Thursday, but acknowledged that “the odds are not with us on this one.”

1. Serenity Disappeared From the Black Hills Children’s Home in February 2019; 2 Employees Who Were Watching Her at the Time Were Later Fired

Two of the facility’s employees were later fired after Serenity’s disappearance, the Argus Leader reported.

A grandmother and her granddaughter were dropping off another child at the time and spotted Serenity running off; the grandmother alerted staff at the children’s home while her granddaughter stayed in the car and watched Serenity disappear into the trees, SD News Watch reported. This was the last confirmed sighting of Serenity.

2. The Search for Serenity Went on for Months, Spanning 4,500 Miles of Rough, Wooded Terrain & Involving 1,200 People

The mass effort to find the girl would sprawl into one of the most exhaustive missing persons searches in South Dakota history, a local NBC affiliate reported in August 2019. More than 1,000 people from 60 different agencies participated in those first six months, the outlet reported.

By January 2020, the search effort slowed, but ended up covering 4,500 miles of rough terrain, with more than 220 leads exhausted and 465 interviews conducted, SD News Watch reported.

3. Law Enforcement & Doctors Expressed Doubt About Serenity’s Chances for Survival Alone in the South Dakota Winter; Cadaver Dogs Have Picked Up Scents, but Have Found No Remains

Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom told the Rapid City Journal in February, one year after Serenity’s disappearance, that the girl’s small size and the chill of the region’s winters made the searchers fear for the worst, although many had still not given up.

“In terms of Serenity specifically, she’s very small, she’s 4-foot-9, roughly 90-some pounds, so if she’s in the woods and got lost, at the point you’re becoming hypothermic, there’s the potential that you find a spot to curl up to get warm, under a rock ledge or next to a log,” he told the outlet.

4. Serenity’s Adoptive Parents Still Have Not Lost All Hope & Last Week Reached Out to the Retired FBI Agents at Veracity IIR to Restart the Search

Dennard and Gentry, Serenity’s adoptive parents, have since divorced, but both continued to feel strongly that Serenity may yet be found, the Argus Leader reported.

“As far as what I think happened, it changes every day,” Dennard told the outlet in February. “But I think she’s out there; I truly don’t think somebody picked her up. I think she liked to run and she wouldn’t run very far, but she liked to see people looking for her. I think she watched people look for her and I think she went too far and got lost. That’s just Serenity, and she had done that before.”

5. Doug Kouns, a Retired FBI Agent & CEO of Veracity IIR, Told Heavy the Odds ‘Aren’t Good,’ but They Are Gearing Up for an Extensive Re-Investigation

Kouns told Heavy on Thursday that his investigators are still brushing up on the circumstances of Serenity’s disappearance — “We’re kind of in sponge mode,” he said.

The case is “pretty cold,” but investigators have an extensive plan in place, based on cycles of intelligence and new or redone interviews.

“We’ll do as much research as we can,” Kouns said. “We’ll look for gaps and peopke that we think we might want to interview again. We’ll reach out to the investigators who worked on this already and hopefully they’ll be cooperative and share with us what they’ve done, maybe some insights that haven’t been made public.”

Kouns says he believes Veracity IIR will be the first private investigation firm to take on Serenity’s case.

“We’ll use the principles we used to use at the FBI,” he said. “Let the facts guide our investigation and use the intl cycle to figure out what questions need to be answered and how they’ll be answered. We’ll collect our intel, process it and analyze it, then produce a set of more detailed questions, just fine-tuning it each time around.”

As for the odds of finding Serenity alive?

“I have to be realistic: The odds are not with us on this one,” Kouns said. “The longer it goes, it just gets much worse. I hate to be pessimistic, but the statistics would say the odds aren’t good.”

1599443140929.png
 
A little recap and a bit more on the PI.

Serenity Dennard: Missing 9-Year-Old’s Family Hires Retired FBI to Find Her

Serenity Dennard is a 9-year-old South Dakota girl who disappeared on February 3, 2019, and was the subject of one of the most extensive missing persons searches in the state’s history.

This week, her adoptive parents, Chad Dennard and Darcie Gentry, have revived the search, hiring a private investigation firm made up of FBI and police veterans in hope of finally tracking their daughter down.

Doug Kouns, a retired FBI agent with Veracity IIR, the Indiana-based firm hired by Serenity’s parents, gave Heavy an overview of his strategy in the fresh search for the girl on Thursday, but acknowledged that “the odds are not with us on this one.”

1. Serenity Disappeared From the Black Hills Children’s Home in February 2019; 2 Employees Who Were Watching Her at the Time Were Later Fired

Two of the facility’s employees were later fired after Serenity’s disappearance, the Argus Leader reported.

A grandmother and her granddaughter were dropping off another child at the time and spotted Serenity running off; the grandmother alerted staff at the children’s home while her granddaughter stayed in the car and watched Serenity disappear into the trees, SD News Watch reported. This was the last confirmed sighting of Serenity.

2. The Search for Serenity Went on for Months, Spanning 4,500 Miles of Rough, Wooded Terrain & Involving 1,200 People

The mass effort to find the girl would sprawl into one of the most exhaustive missing persons searches in South Dakota history, a local NBC affiliate reported in August 2019. More than 1,000 people from 60 different agencies participated in those first six months, the outlet reported.

By January 2020, the search effort slowed, but ended up covering 4,500 miles of rough terrain, with more than 220 leads exhausted and 465 interviews conducted, SD News Watch reported.

3. Law Enforcement & Doctors Expressed Doubt About Serenity’s Chances for Survival Alone in the South Dakota Winter; Cadaver Dogs Have Picked Up Scents, but Have Found No Remains

Pennington County Sheriff Kevin Thom told the Rapid City Journal in February, one year after Serenity’s disappearance, that the girl’s small size and the chill of the region’s winters made the searchers fear for the worst, although many had still not given up.

“In terms of Serenity specifically, she’s very small, she’s 4-foot-9, roughly 90-some pounds, so if she’s in the woods and got lost, at the point you’re becoming hypothermic, there’s the potential that you find a spot to curl up to get warm, under a rock ledge or next to a log,” he told the outlet.

4. Serenity’s Adoptive Parents Still Have Not Lost All Hope & Last Week Reached Out to the Retired FBI Agents at Veracity IIR to Restart the Search

Dennard and Gentry, Serenity’s adoptive parents, have since divorced, but both continued to feel strongly that Serenity may yet be found, the Argus Leader reported.

“As far as what I think happened, it changes every day,” Dennard told the outlet in February. “But I think she’s out there; I truly don’t think somebody picked her up. I think she liked to run and she wouldn’t run very far, but she liked to see people looking for her. I think she watched people look for her and I think she went too far and got lost. That’s just Serenity, and she had done that before.”

5. Doug Kouns, a Retired FBI Agent & CEO of Veracity IIR, Told Heavy the Odds ‘Aren’t Good,’ but They Are Gearing Up for an Extensive Re-Investigation

Kouns told Heavy on Thursday that his investigators are still brushing up on the circumstances of Serenity’s disappearance — “We’re kind of in sponge mode,” he said.

The case is “pretty cold,” but investigators have an extensive plan in place, based on cycles of intelligence and new or redone interviews.

“We’ll do as much research as we can,” Kouns said. “We’ll look for gaps and peopke that we think we might want to interview again. We’ll reach out to the investigators who worked on this already and hopefully they’ll be cooperative and share with us what they’ve done, maybe some insights that haven’t been made public.”

Kouns says he believes Veracity IIR will be the first private investigation firm to take on Serenity’s case.

“We’ll use the principles we used to use at the FBI,” he said. “Let the facts guide our investigation and use the intl cycle to figure out what questions need to be answered and how they’ll be answered. We’ll collect our intel, process it and analyze it, then produce a set of more detailed questions, just fine-tuning it each time around.”

As for the odds of finding Serenity alive?

“I have to be realistic: The odds are not with us on this one,” Kouns said. “The longer it goes, it just gets much worse. I hate to be pessimistic, but the statistics would say the odds aren’t good.”

View attachment 6666
Hmm. It is rare for me but I am going to sit and think about this one. I know what my initial instinct is...
 
I don't remember the bit about the cadaver dogs. But apparently that info was published in April 2019.


Pennington County Sheriff's Office suspends search for Serenity Dennard​

The Pennington County Sheriff’s Office is ending its search for Serenity Dennard, nearly two years after she ran away from a rural group home near Rockerville. The investigation remains open.

“Absent new information, the search for Serenity Dennard is being suspended,” the office said Thursday in a news release. “The investigation will remain open, and we encourage the public to report any new information or tips. Our collective thoughts and prayers remain with Serenity Dennard’s family.”

The last search took place on Jan. 13, Sheriff Kevin Thom told the Journal.


Cadaver dogs picked up a scent near a creek, the sheriff said. Thom said K9 handlers told him it’s possible that she died along the creek and her body was swept away during heavy rains.
 
I don't remember the bit about the cadaver dogs. But apparently that info was published in April 2019.


Pennington County Sheriff's Office suspends search for Serenity Dennard​

The Pennington County Sheriff’s Office is ending its search for Serenity Dennard, nearly two years after she ran away from a rural group home near Rockerville. The investigation remains open.

“Absent new information, the search for Serenity Dennard is being suspended,” the office said Thursday in a news release. “The investigation will remain open, and we encourage the public to report any new information or tips. Our collective thoughts and prayers remain with Serenity Dennard’s family.”

The last search took place on Jan. 13, Sheriff Kevin Thom told the Journal.


Cadaver dogs picked up a scent near a creek, the sheriff said. Thom said K9 handlers told him it’s possible that she died along the creek and her body was swept away during heavy rains.
If I remember correctly and I won't swear to it, it does not mean it was her scent but they did a slight hit on the scent of death. I mean cadaver dogs scent for a dead body right, where a scent dog looks for the actual person's trail?

So sad over this child to this day.
 
If I remember correctly and I won't swear to it, it does not mean it was her scent but they did a slight hit on the scent of death. I mean cadaver dogs scent for a dead body right, where a scent dog looks for the actual person's trail?

So sad over this child to this day.
Depends. The linked article said they were actual HRD (human remains detection) cadaver dogs, so they are trained to only alert on the scent of human remains, not animal remains.
So no, it wouldn't absolutely mean it was her, but with her being a missing person in the immediate area, it would be pretty likely.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,030
Messages
243,594
Members
981
Latest member
Alicerar
Back
Top Bottom