Karen Read accused of backing into boyfriend and leaving him to die *MISTRIAL*

1691951367971.png

This woman didn't do this. I'd be willing to bet that someone in the house did it. Someone in the house looked up "How long will it take for somebody to die in the cold." Karen couldn't have done that search.

Is there a cover up conspiracy?

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Just a reminder of the wounds the prosecution is trying to say insisting are evidence of a auto hitting him, in reverse, at 24 mph and the broken tail light pieces through his sweatshirt are what caused these and are trying to get a defense witness denied from testifying..

Full House Reaction GIF


View attachment 22274
Also, if they are going with the tail light pieces being the cause of these injuries, why is there no evidence of his skin/blood on ANY of those bajillion pieces they claim did this? Those wounds would have definitely left "something" behind.
 

Updated: 9:35 AM EDT Jun 20, 2024
David Bienick
Todd Kazakiewich


<snip>

  • 9:30 a.m. The jury enters. Trooper Guarino returns to the stand. Prosecutor Adam Lally resumes his direct examination about Read's phone logs from Jan 28 and Jan 29.
  • 9:25 a.m. Judge says accident reconstructionist Daniel Wolfe will be allowed to testify about his findings but says she has reserves of his colleague Andrew Rentschler. She will rule on that at a later time.
  • 9:20 a.m. Judge rules defense witness Dr. Marie Russell will be allowed to testify. Says her testimony will be limited to whether marks on O'Keefe's arms are consistent with animal attack. Russell will not be able to testify about whether they are inconsistent with motor vehicle crash.
  • G'morning. Day 27 of testimony. We expect to hear more today from Tpr Nicholas Guarino. On Monday, he testified about text message Read and O'Keefe exchanged they died before he died when the argued. We may also learn if the judge will allow three defense witnesses.
 

By Marc Fortier and Asher Klein • Published 3 hours ago • Updated 43 seconds ago​


Cannone's ruling on defense's expert witnesses​

Recapping Tuesday's hearing, called a voir dire hearing, Cannone said she will allow the defense's dog bite expert, Dr. Marie Russell, to testify on a limited basis. The prosecution had sought to exclude Russell's testimony.

"She'll be allowed only to opine whether or not the marks on John O'Keefe's arm were the result of an animal attack, Cannone said, noting her specialized knowledge in the field.

Russell told the judge and lawyers on Tuesday that she'd reached out to the defense last month after hearing about the ongoing trial.

At least one of the accident reconstruction experts, Daniel Wolfe and Andrew Rentschler of high-profile forensic consulting engineering company ARCCA, will also be allowed to testify.

Wolfe, who specializes in accident reconstruction, got the full OK. But Cannone said that Rentschler, as a biomedical engineer, is not qualified to testify on the medical cause of injuries under Massachusetts law and court precedent.

She said she would hear arguments on that later on, and had the trial continue.

Trooper Guarino back on the stand​

Massachusetts State Police forensic expert Trooper Nicholas Guarino was called back to the stand.
 

Updated: 9:35 AM EDT Jun 20, 2024
David Bienick
Todd Kazakiewich


<snip>
  • 10 a.m. Guarino says they also found a Waze search on O'Keefe's phone for 34 Fairview Road, says it shows phone arrived at the address at 12:24am and stayed within a 3-feet area for the entire night.
  • 9:55 a.m. Guarino says he was also able to extract health data from O'Keefe's cell phone showing how many steps he took. But Guarino says the data is not always active. "Just waving it around could cause it to think you're moving," he says.
  • 9:50 a.m. Lally plays the eight voicemails. In some she repeatedly swears at him. In one there's no audio. In the last one, from 6:08am, we hear the pulse of the windshield wipers as 911 is called from the scene. Read is heard screaming in the background.
  • 9:40 a.m. Guarino says Read tried to call O'Keefe's phone more than 50 times after 12:30am on Jan 29th, says she left eight voicemails.
  • 9:37 a.m. Guarino reads text messages from Read to O'Keefe where she tells him she's going home, the kids are alone and she's in Mansfield. (She did not go to Mansfield at that time.)
  • 9:35 a.m. Guarino reads text messages between Read and Laura Sullivan. Lally notes that Read tells Sullivan O'Keefe was found at 5 a.m. (an hour earlier than when she arrived at the scene with McCabe and Roberts).
 

Updated: 9:35 AM EDT Jun 20, 2024
David Bienick
Todd Kazakiewich


<snip>
  • 10:15 a.m. Guarino says they determined where the phone was located at 12:25 a.m. within an area of three feet, says that area is 72 feet from the front door of the house.
  • 10:12 a.m. Guarino says he was able to map the route O'Keefe's phone took from the Waterfall bar to 34 Fairview Rd. Says they drove on Cedarcrest, went past Fairview Rd and made 3-point turn to come back to the intersection.
  • 10:07 a.m. Guarino says he and Proctor went to scene on Feb 8 and took measurements, including distance between where O'Keefe was found and the house.
  • 10:05 a.m. Guarino says the geo-location precision depends on the cell phone signal strength. Says the signal at 34 Fairview Rd is "not great."
 

By Marc Fortier and Asher Klein • Published 3 hours ago • Updated 43 seconds ago​


<snip>

Trooper Guarino testifies about Read's voicemails​

Massachusetts State Police forensic expert Trooper Nicholas Guarino was called back to the stand.

He shared texts between Read and Laura Sullivan, a close friend of O'Keefe's who has previously testified in the trial, from after O'Keefe's death.

Guarino was then asked to share texts between Read and O'Keefe, in which she indicated she was going back to her house. The last read, "I'm back in Mansfield. The kids are home alone."

Assistant District Attorney Adam Lally moved on to the phone call record between Read and O'Keefe, which involved more than 50 calls, though there was no indication that the pair spoke.

"There were eight voicemails from Mr. O'Keefe's phone from the 29th until the phone was discovered, all from Ms. Read, no one else," Guarino said. He also noted that Read's phone indicated she connected to the wifi at his house at 12:36 a.m.

All eight voicemails were played for the court — the first was left on O'Keefe's phone a minute after her phone connected to the wifi at his house.

"John, I f------ hate you!" she said in that voicemail.

The second, from 12:42 a.m., only played the sound of undetermined beeps, walking and bumping.

At 12:59, Read left a third voicemail saying, "John, I'm here with your f------ kids. Nobody knows where the f--- you are, you f------ pervert."

The fourth message, at 1:02 a.m., has no content. At 1:11 a.m., she leaves a longer message, screaming that she's with his neice and nephew and again calls him a pervert.

At 1:18 a.m., Read leaves a sixth message, sayig she needs to go home and ending, "You're f------ another girl…you're a f------ loser, f--- yourself!"

The next message, from 5:23 a.m., Read can be heard screaming.

The eighth and final message, from 6:08 a.m., has been played before in the trial. In it, mumbling, screaming and the sound of a vehicle's wipers can be heard — it's from when Read, Jennifer McCabe and Kerry Roberts were at the Fairview Road home, having found O'Keefe's body. Guarino noted someone can be heard on the phone with 911.

Read also made three calls to a contact listed as her mother, at 1:10 a.m., 4:40 a.m. and 4:42 a.m. — the last of which was answered, Guarino testified. There was also a call placed to a contact listed as "dad."
 

Updated: 9:35 AM EDT Jun 20, 2024
David Bienick
Todd Kazakiewich


<snip>
  • 10:15 a.m. Guarino says they determined where the phone was located at 12:25 a.m. within an area of three feet, says that area is 72 feet from the front door of the house.
  • 10:12 a.m. Guarino says he was able to map the route O'Keefe's phone took from the Waterfall bar to 34 Fairview Rd. Says they drove on Cedarcrest, went past Fairview Rd and made 3-point turn to come back to the intersection.
  • 10:07 a.m. Guarino says he and Proctor went to scene on Feb 8 and took measurements, including distance between where O'Keefe was found and the house.
  • 10:05 a.m. Guarino says the geo-location precision depends on the cell phone signal strength. Says the signal at 34 Fairview Rd is "not great."

In a heavily populated suburb, I doubt the signal is "not great". For a phone company to skimp on service for an upper middle class area, doesn't make sense to me. I'm sure the defense will address that with one of their experts.
 

By Marc Fortier and Asher Klein • Published 3 hours ago • Updated 43 seconds ago​


<snip>

John O'Keefe's phone, GPS data discussed​

Lally turned to the location data from O'Keefe's phone, which Guarino analyzed during the investigation.

In previous statements in court, the prosecution and defense have told vastly different stories based on the data — the defense has alleged that data on the phone indicated O'Keefe went inside the home.
 

Updated: 9:35 AM EDT Jun 20, 2024
David Bienick
Todd Kazakiewich


<snip>

  • 11:35 a.m. Jury returns. Guarino is back on the stand. Yannetti begins cross-examination by asking about his experience in computer forensics. He's trying to cast doubt on Guarino's ability to assess the "hos long to die in cold" search.
  • 11:30 a.m. After a recess, Assistant District Attorney Laura McLaughlin tells the judge prosecutors want to show jurors a google search for DUI attorneys that Read allegedly conducted at 1:27pm on the day O'Keefe died.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,010
Messages
241,087
Members
970
Latest member
NickGoGetta
Back
Top Bottom