ELIZABETH COLLINS & LYRIC COOK: Young cousins kidnapped and murdered in Evansdale, IA - July 2012

1594431706810.png

On July 13th, 2012 Elizabeth Collins, age 8, and her cousin Lyric Cook, age 10, went for a bike ride in Evansdale. The two never returned and their abandoned bikes were later located on a trail in the southeast corner of Meyers Lake later in that day. A large search was executed in Evansdale and their disappearance was investigated by local, state and federal officials.

On December 5th, 2012 hunters in the Seven Bridges Wildlife Park discovered the bodies of Elizabeth and Lyric. Seven Bridges Wildlife Park is approximately 25 miles from where they disappeared.

To this day, no arrests in their disappearance and murder have been made.


Tips may be submitted by calling the Evansdale Police Department at 319-232-6682, emailing the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigations at OURMISSINGIOWAGIRLS@DPS.STATE.IA.US, by calling Cedar Valley Crime Stoppers at 855-300-8477, using Tipsoft by texting the word Cedar plus the tip to 274637 (Crimes), or by visiting WWW.CVCRIMESTOP.COM and submitting the information online. A person is eligible for the reward regardless of which of these specific methods is used to submit the information.
 

10th annual 'Ride for the Girls' raises money and awareness for unsolved cases​

Over 140 motorcycles roared through eastern Iowa Saturday for the 10th annual 'Ride for the Girls' event. A fundraiser honoring Evansdale cousins Lyric Cook-Morrisey and Elizabeth Collins.

Investigators have not been able to crack the cold case, and they have not made any arrests. There is currently a $100,000 reward for information. Law enforcement have received nearly 2,000 leads into the investigation since the girls first went missing, which include 117 in the past 10 months.


Several of Collins' personal friends were volunteers at the ride. Pastor Q from Hope City Church blessed the bikes before taking off, commending the group behind Collins and Collins himself for bringing people together and letting them know they're never alone.


Collins says it's been their support and the community's support that has helped him get through.

"They've carried me," he said, adding, "we've had great community support, and I think everyone around here wants to see this solved, so it just means a lot to us."
Although the first ride held a decade ago was solely dedicated to the girls, the ride now encompasses several different unsolved murders and disappearance cases across the country.

"I think it means a lot to the other families that are kinda getting involved too that are going through similar things that they know they're not forgotten as well," Collins said. "We're bringing other people in that are going through the same things, and we're kinda helping each other along the way."
With the community behind him, Collins is confident Lyric and Elizabeth will soon have justice, as well as the other cases he keeps close to his heart.

"If anything, we're getting stronger. We're not going anywhere. We're going to continue to get this case out there until it's solved," he said. "We want to bring this monster to justice and help as many people along the way as we can."
All proceeds raised during Saturday's ride will go towards the Elizabeth Collins Foundation, which supports families of missing persons. You can learn more about the foundation and ways you can help out HERE.
 

Delphi arrest of Richard Allen gives hope to dad in eerie similar case of Elizabeth Collins & Lyric Cook-Morrissey​

A BREAKTHROUGH in the Delphi murder investigation has given hope to a father who lost his young daughter and niece in an eerily similar double homicide that remains unsolved 10 years later.

Cousins Elizabeth Collins, 8, and Lyric Cook-Morrissey, 10, vanished while riding their bikes around the small town of Evansdale, in Iowa, on July 13, 2012.

Less than five years later, some 317 miles away, 14-year-old Liberty German and her best friend Abigail Williams, 13, were reported missing in Delphi, Indiana, having last been seen hiking a local trail.


But speculation has mounted in recent years that the two cases could be connected and a number of parallels have been drawn.

Among them is that both murders took place in small Midwestern towns of less than a few thousand people, both involved two young girls who were out exploring in nature when they were abducted, and all four bodies were left on land typically frequented by hunters.

Theories have been put forward that a serial killer could be operating in the Midwestern US, though evidence to support such claims currently appears scarce.

For Elizabeth's dad, Drew Collins, the likelihood his daughter's death is linked to the Delphi case is not totally out of the realm of possibility, though he believes there's only a "very small chance" it could be.

However, what has given him a renewed cause for optimism in his quest to get justice for his daughter was a bombshell announcement made by police in Indiana last week that an arrest had been made in connection with Abby and Libby's deaths.

The suspect was named as 50-year-old Richard Allen, a married father-of-one and local CVS employee. He has pleaded not guilty to two counts of murder.

Investigators are still exploring whether others may have been involved.

Drew said the potential breakthrough has "definitely" given him confidence that the culprit behind the murders of Elizabeth and Lyric will one day be unmasked.

"That guy [Richard Allen] wasn't even on anybody's radar, which just shows you these things can take time," said Drew, 51.

"We have a lot of good detectives working on this case and a lot of other dedicated people, and they aren't going to quit until we find who did this.

"It could take 10 years, it could take 20 years, it could take longer ... but we're going to find who did this, it's just a matter of when.

"We're going to expose that person, their whole family is going to know what they did, and everyone will know what they did to those two beautiful little girls."
 
it appears that they are
This headline is deceiving. It sounds as if they are probing him/questioning him but they are simply evaluating whether he could be from their end imo. It really says pretty much what the other did but ads LE remarks to what the dad said who doesn't think it likely the same guy in these crimes.

What is interesting to me and I think I had already heard it but wasn't positive is that he is seeking private counsel. This to me might mean his wife believes in his innocence. They are married and to retain private counsel is going to cost a small fortune. Hard to say if they have any savings but we know the home is an asset. He may have his own work retirement account I guess is possible but that is still a marital asset or can be when married. My point is if she is okay with him mortgaging their home or taking savings then...

I was actually hoping family would encourage him to plead guilty as this is so heinous and the family has to live it now too.
 
This headline is deceiving. It sounds as if they are probing him/questioning him but they are simply evaluating whether he could be from their end imo. It really says pretty much what the other did but ads LE remarks to what the dad said who doesn't think it likely the same guy in these crimes.

What is interesting to me and I think I had already heard it but wasn't positive is that he is seeking private counsel. This to me might mean his wife believes in his innocence. They are married and to retain private counsel is going to cost a small fortune. Hard to say if they have any savings but we know the home is an asset. He may have his own work retirement account I guess is possible but that is still a marital asset or can be when married. My point is if she is okay with him mortgaging their home or taking savings then...

I was actually hoping family would encourage him to plead guilty as this is so heinous and the family has to live it now too.
by them stating they are evaluating it, means they are looking into it.
 
by them stating they are evaluating it, means they are looking into it.
I know but the probing headline makes it sound as if they are talking to him and he is talking to no one. They didn't use "evaluate" there. Not a big deal, just saying misleading to get the read/the click. Not uncommon.
 

Ride and Drive to be held in memory of Elizabeth Collins, Lyric Cook​

The Elizabeth Collins Foundation will host the 11th annual Ride and Drive Memorial Event on Saturday, July 15 in memory of Elizabeth Collins and Lyric Cook.

Registration for the event will begin at 8 a.m. at Lofty’s Lounge, located at 3480 Lafayette Road in Evansdale. The ride and drive begins at 11 a.m. There will also be raffles and a silent auction. People can also become a sponsor for the event.

People can preregister for the event for $20, which includes a T-shirt.

Funds raised from the event will benefit Angels Park, Cedar Valley Crime Stoppers and the Elizabeth Collins Foundation Community Mission.
 

"I just feel more connected to her here. I'd rather come here," says Drew Collins about the Angels Park Memorial Island​

11 years and still unsolved, but the annual "Ride & Drive For The Girls" is coming up July 15 to help keep the memory alive.

"Some days are good days and some days are bad days. Holidays are really hard, says Drew Collins, the father of Elizabeth Collins.


Drew admits he's frustrated that the case remains unsolved. It's painful for his family. "Different holidays are going to be harder for each of us, you know. So, I think you know, we're all doing the best we can."

While Drew still visits Elizabeth's grave on occasion, he would rather go to the Angels Park Memorial Island at Meyers Lake in Evansdale.

"I like to come out here rather than the cemetery. It's just more peaceful here. I just feel more connected to her here than there. I go out and I visit.

I rather come here (Angels Park) than the gravesite.

When talking about the cemetery, Drew says, "It's like her body is right there, but she's not there. So, I come out here and I feel a lot more peaceful than I do out there. I come out here and I usually go there and I read all the different cases and it's just sad."

Originally, the Angels Park paid tribute to Elizabeth and Lyric as well as three other female victims of violent crime from the area; Lindsay Nichols, Donissha Hill, and Evelyn Miller.

But, in recent years, more and more memorials have been established on the Island. Some families plant trees or flowers and erect memorial plaques.

Drew Collins has been encouraged by this and says, "

"It's just some place beside the cemetery they can go and just reflect. It's also good for parents to come out here and show their kids this, because you know, kids think it can never happen to them."
 

Case of murdered Evansdale cousins remains unsolved 11 years after bodies found​

Tuesday marked 11 years since the bodies of Lyric Cook-Morrisey and Elizabeth Collins were found in Bremer County.

More than a decade later, investigators are still searching for the person or people responsible for the abduction and killing. They disappeared in July 2012 while riding their bikes near Meyers lake.

No one has been arrested or charged in the case. Investigators have not released their causes of death to the public. They believe that is information only the killer would know.

Elizabeth’s father, Drew Collins, says he checks in weekly with the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation.

“I can’t think of anything that’s been harder in my life than losing Elizabeth,” Collins said. “You’re trying to make sense out of the something that is very senseless. I look at those little girls and I think, ‘How could any normal human being hurt those little girls?’”

The reward to find the person or persons who murdered Lyric and Elizabeth is now more than $100,000.
 

Case of murdered Evansdale cousins remains unsolved 11 years after bodies found​

Tuesday marked 11 years since the bodies of Lyric Cook-Morrisey and Elizabeth Collins were found in Bremer County.

More than a decade later, investigators are still searching for the person or people responsible for the abduction and killing. They disappeared in July 2012 while riding their bikes near Meyers lake.

No one has been arrested or charged in the case. Investigators have not released their causes of death to the public. They believe that is information only the killer would know.

Elizabeth’s father, Drew Collins, says he checks in weekly with the Iowa Division of Criminal Investigation.

“I can’t think of anything that’s been harder in my life than losing Elizabeth,” Collins said. “You’re trying to make sense out of the something that is very senseless. I look at those little girls and I think, ‘How could any normal human being hurt those little girls?’”

The reward to find the person or persons who murdered Lyric and Elizabeth is now more than $100,000.
Apparently there is no connection to Delphi as many (self included at times, never sold on it one way or the other) thought there might be but it has been some time now since the Delphi arrest and no further charges against Delphi Allen or hint of same.

But then there is no connection of Delphi and RA to KK yet either and I believe there is one of some kind...

I guess a year plus isn't that long when you figure how slow our system is these days...

RIP girls and hopefully your justice will come. Whether related or not.

Dad is right, how can you look at children and be a normal human and hurt them like that. :(
 
Apparently there is no connection to Delphi as many (self included at times, never sold on it one way or the other) thought there might be but it has been some time now since the Delphi arrest and no further charges against Delphi Allen or hint of same.

But then there is no connection of Delphi and RA to KK yet either and I believe there is one of some kind...

I guess a year plus isn't that long when you figure how slow our system is these days...

RIP girls and hopefully your justice will come. Whether related or not.

Dad is right, how can you look at children and be a normal human and hurt them like that. :(
I'll always marvel at the many similarities of the circumstances of the two cases and I still think that if the Evansdale perp isn't Allen, it must be someone a lot like him.
 
I'll always marvel at the many similarities of the circumstances of the two cases and I still think that if the Evansdale perp isn't Allen, it must be someone a lot like him.
I would agree in that two are unusual. And two girls. And two preadolescent or thereabouts girls. And in adjoining states. For ALL of the crime we know of and hear of it is uncanny as we don't hear of such or so many similarities of again TWO out on a hike or bike ride, etc. It isn't like it is IN and OR, these are bordering states with TWO girls and VERY similar crimes. Also not like they are 20 years apart either.

I can't ignore it either. It is not off my radar. And I am midwest and know traveling to adjoining states as we all do where we live... It is not far fetched and again, for all of the crime most of us have followed of which there are too many, two girls around this age murdered on a carefree day off seemingly out of the blue is unusual. In two adjoining states with, as you say, many similarities.

Is this a unique sick fantasy (two young girls) or is it an SK or budding one who wants to come in as different and superior to all SKs with TWO victims in every crime who he so magnificently (in his opinion) controlled and killed in his murders and was not caught for (or so he hoped/planned) to be more important, more significant, more newsworthy and historical in his pervert mind than any before him?

Yeah I have not dismissed it believe me. Abby and Libby they tried to say through the years it had nothing to do with social media but it did imo. If you take away SM, internet, etc. these seem like very opportunistic random crimes on days two girls just decided to go do something...

It ABSOLUTELY cannot be ignored unless they have absolute proof it could not be the same killer. AGREE.

So many are seeing Allen (and sadly a lot of others) as this poor abused innocent could do no wrong average quiet unassuming man. I don't see him that way at ALL. I see a monster. I see mind games. I see his ways and silence as a deeply disturbed man living a double life which most of these types are. Imo. Make no mistake about it, Allen is running the show/his own show. This is not at you, it is my strength in my belief as to what is going on.

I will however state that of course he is not convicted and I could be wrong but this is my opinion. He placed himself there. He admits to seeing certain people because he knew they saw him at this spot or that spot. LE did not frame him and manufacture that he was there.

He definitely could be responsible for Lyric and Elizabeth. Or as you say a similar type could. I agree. Too much to be ignored.
 
Is this a unique sick fantasy (two young girls) or is it an SK or budding one who wants to come in as different and superior to all SKs with TWO victims in every crime who he so magnificently (in his opinion) controlled and killed in his murders and was not caught for (or so he hoped/planned) to be more important, more significant, more newsworthy and historical in his pervert mind than any before him?
I don't think so. I just think that instead of one vulnerable victim, he found two.
He definitely could be responsible for Lyric and Elizabeth. Or as you say a similar type could. I agree. Too much to be ignored.
And I think there are probably other similarities that we don't yet know, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if this perp is also a local and probably lived within a couple of miles of that lake trail.
 
I don't think so. I just think that instead of one vulnerable victim, he found two.

And I think there are probably other similarities that we don't yet know, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if this perp is also a local and probably lived within a couple of miles of that lake trail.
Could be but I think two could also be the goal. For a few reasons and some of them pretty sick. Or as I said just for the sheer notoriety of always killing two if this was his aim for fame It is true in A & L's case he could have hoped to meet only one but the two came together or not true I don't mean so much as I mean possible. In this case, it is entirely possible he was looking for any untended minor females he could find alone with no adult. It's really hard to say. He (or they, different cases) may have gotten a very sick satisfaction of both girls being scared to death but also over the top in watching what was done to the other girl before themselves, etc. I mean these are monsters we can't almost comprehend to even do what they do in the first place. Maybe just one lone child wouldn't give the killer/s the thrill two did. You take a lone vulnerable child, do your sick thing and that's it. With two, well you do but then your fantasy is not done and kaput you have the other yet. I HATE these thoughts but just trying to explain what I mean. They say most SK fantasies do not live up to their expectations... And I also consider the fame/notoriety/almost SK competition of one that kills two. And not so young defenseless children in the sense of five year olds. But teens or preteens or around there. That's pretty brazen. Stupid in a day of cell phones and video etc. but brazen.

But yeah it could have just been happenstance that there were two. But I'm not convinced these girls were not seen in town, etc. first. OR even who knows, lured out somehow. I know both cases but I know Delphi better. I was longer before these two were found was it not?

But anyhow I'm also not convinced he was someone who was local or lived near the lake trail.

But then we do not know as you say what investigators know.

I do know this. I'd be hard put to believe this or Delphi was their only crime or each (if different perp's) only crime. And again TWO. It is possible but a bit of a one off and hard to believe if so...

It's very different but I think of Jacob Wetterling. Was there not THREE boys and the other two were younger and the perp (he was local as found years later) did not try to take all three, he only took Jacob. Again, two is imo very unusual. I as you probably have have followed tons of cases for years and these are the only two I can think of like this. Don't get me wrong, I know Dylan and Shast Groene were both taken. But that's a boy and a girl and I am talking here the same kind of looks of these girls, general age range the same, these two a bit younger than A & L etc. It's just hard to ignore and again with neighboring states... Is it five years apart...?

But who knows. Impossible to know the type or mindset of someone so sick.

This one is unsolved. It is also possible it could be family or family friend and that was often wondered in Delphi too. A & L were friends, these two were family/cousins. It seems in both cases some care was taken in expecting both sets of girls to check in, stay together, etc. as to safety am I wrong on that?

That's the other thing on these murders is children and even young adults are taught the buddy system. You go nowhere alone, you stay together, you have someone with you. Parents follow that or believe in it too. Well that didn't stop this perp/s. It is so brazen, again. How could he know one wouldn't get away, go screaming, someone hear, etc. For this reason too I think he may have looked for two for the sheer challenge, thrill, getting away with double and being able to control and take down two.

Let's say it is the same killer... These two were first and younger and likely easier sorry to say. Went off without much a hitch and he's never been caught or even looked at and it was outside his home territory maybe but somewhere he knew possibly. And he decides to go a bit older and for more of a challenge and right at home territory. Hence A & L. This time though he is seen by others on the trail before the murders. The thrill goes up from that. And even after goes in and confesses to being there which maddeningly the significance of is lost on some DNR guy who isn't even an investigator. He goes without apprehension again. But then video of him comes out and that strikes fear. But then nothing happens... He changes appearance, watches how often he speaks or how, etc. The boldness grows. He poses in front of killer sketches in a pic.


I don't have a point, I'm just thinking out loud as I write this. I am not convinced these murders are the same perp but I'm not convinced they are not either. We don't know enough.

I am checking my memory here, is it not true in both cases, they did not say whether the girls were or were not s xually ass lted?

And in this one these girls were taken elsewhere were they not? Wasn't where they disappeared from different than where found and the bikes? In A & L it is rumored too where they laid is not where they were killed,, staging, posing, etc. I don't know that in this case here there was any staging though was there?

Either way we have one sick F that was running around for years and is now incarcerated or there were two and one is still out there. And that's unacceptable.

Many made a lot of the similar looks of the two sets of girls. Even initials and names, not so sure about that but A and L in one and E & L in another but depending on niickname or full name That though would take planning and stalking, etc. I do think Abby and Libby were a plan. Not as sure on this one but I wouldn't exclude it.
 
But I'm not convinced these girls were not seen in town, etc. first. OR even who knows, lured out somehow. I know both cases but I know Delphi better. I was longer before these two were found was it not?
Yeah, it was months before the Evansdale girl's remains were found, and yeah, I've also wondered whether the girls were seen by the perp before they reached the lake trail.
It's very different but I think of Jacob Wetterling. Was there not THREE boys and the other two were younger and the perp (he was local as found years later) did not try to take all three, he only took Jacob.
Yes, there were three and btw, if you don't recall, that's a case where the perp had seen the victim elsewhere just prior to their abduction. The perp had seen the boys in the store where they'd gone to rent a movie.
I as you probably have have followed tons of cases for years and these are the only two I can think of like this.
Well, as I recall, there was another case in Iowa in which two teen girls were abducted together. One was murdered but the other got away.
Btw, I thought the perp was a good suspect for this case but LE seemed to eliminate him and I don't remember whether they ever said how or why.
I am checking my memory here, is it not true in both cases, they did not say whether the girls were or were not s xually ass lted?

And in this one these girls were taken elsewhere were they not? Wasn't where they disappeared from different than where found and the bikes?
Yes, the remains were found about (IIRC) 25 miles away, and the bikes and a few other belongings- a purse and I think a cell phone were found near the lake trail.
Re sexual assault, I don't think LE ever commented about that.
 
Yeah, it was months before the Evansdale girl's remains were found, and yeah, I've also wondered whether the girls were seen by the perp before they reached the lake trail.

Yes, there were three and btw, if you don't recall, that's a case where the perp had seen the victim elsewhere just prior to their abduction. The perp had seen the boys in the store where they'd gone to rent a movie.

Well, as I recall, there was another case in Iowa in which two teen girls were abducted together. One was murdered but the other got away.
Btw, I thought the perp was a good suspect for this case but LE seemed to eliminate him and I don't remember whether they ever said how or why.

Yes, the remains were found about (IIRC) 25 miles away, and the bikes and a few other belongings- a purse and I think a cell phone were found near the lake trail.
Re sexual assault, I don't think LE ever commented about that.
yes I thought so as far as Evansdale and finding them and I have always thought the perp saw them and was not necessarily from the lake trail area. of course we can't know but that is my leaning.

yes, on wetterling too. from the midwest and know it well. it was huge and significant in its day long before perp was determined. @Mel70 knows it pretty well also. It was like home terriotry and scary as heck and nearby to both of us/our states.

I do NOT recall offhand or know of the other IA case where one teen got away. Sounds distantly familiar but not sure. As I have said too many cases over too long of a time and sadly a person used to be able to keep up with them but more crime and so constant now... I have a few I'd like to see added here but haven't had time to even bring it up or recall which ones just in the last couple of days.

yeah like i said i know it and pretty well but not as well as delphi. i was pretty sure they were found a ways away and not immediately or even a few days. You say months and that is what I thought for sure at least weeks, several.

Do you think it likely the same killer? As I said I have never been sold either way.

And yeah, I thought SA was never commented on or confirmed. In either case.

You seem to be open to the possibility it was the same killer from what you've said? Or open you said to a similar type right?

I am not sold myself either way and never have been but am open to it. I do find both crimes with TWO unusual and in neighboring states but this one could entirely be something or someone else/different as well. The perp/s in both cases needs to be taken out of society for good.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, it was months before the Evansdale girl's remains were found, and yeah, I've also wondered whether the girls were seen by the perp before they reached the lake trail.

Yes, there were three and btw, if you don't recall, that's a case where the perp had seen the victim elsewhere just prior to their abduction. The perp had seen the boys in the store where they'd gone to rent a movie.

Well, as I recall, there was another case in Iowa in which two teen girls were abducted together. One was murdered but the other got away.
Btw, I thought the perp was a good suspect for this case but LE seemed to eliminate him and I don't remember whether they ever said how or why.

Yes, the remains were found about (IIRC) 25 miles away, and the bikes and a few other belongings- a purse and I think a cell phone were found near the lake trail.
Re sexual assault, I don't think LE ever commented about that.
I never heard any comment on assault either. IMO. It was not someone they knew, But an opportunistic killer that had been thinking about it for years. And I would venture to say, Has/Had a violent criminal record that includes crimes against children. It seems to be a pattern. I am always surprised when I see a perpetrator that doesn't have one. But to me l. That just means they haven't been caught. Or charges were dropped. But a look into their background, There were signs.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,034
Messages
244,549
Members
983
Latest member
yepugotme2
Back
Top Bottom