GUYMON — On Wednesday, Texas County Associate District Judge A. Clark Jett ordered a consolidation of the cases for the purposes of a preliminary hearing for four of the accused
www.woodwardnews.net
Judge combines preliminary hearings for four of five defendants in Texas County murder of two women
On Wednesday, Texas County Associate District Judge A. Clark Jett ordered a consolidation of the cases for the purposes of a preliminary hearing for four of the accused in the double slaying of two Kansas moms – Jilian Kelley, 39, and Veronica Butler, 27, according to court documents.
A preliminary hearing is a judicial process that determines if there is enough evidence to bind over the defendants for a trial.
All five defendants, Tifany M. Adams, 55, Tad Cullum, 43, Cole Twombly, 50, Cora Twombly, 49, and Paul Grice, 32, were arrested in April in connection to the kidnapping and murders of Butler and Kelley on March 30.
All five are being held without bail in Texas County Jail. Adams, Cullum and both Twomblys were arrested April 18. Grice was arrested April 29.
After six court appearances for preliminary hearing conferences, status hearings and motion dockets in which numerous motions were filed, four of the accused were scheduled to appear for a preliminary hearing at 9 a.m. Dec. 17 in Texas County.
On Wednesday, Grice, who is the fifth defendant in the case, filed a motion to waive his right to a preliminary hearing. The motion was granted, which means he will not appear in the preliminary hearing and is scheduled for “further proceedings” (likely a formal arraignment) at 1 p.m. Feb. 19, 2025, according to Kari Moody, a true crime reporter based in Enid who was present for the proceedings Wednesday.
Grice also waived his right to a speedy trial, Moody said.
Earlier this month, the state filed a motion to consolidate the preliminary hearing. Contained within that document were details regarding the cause of death of both Butler and Kelley.
This was detailed information that had not been released publicly for months, since April when the Office of the Oklahoma Chief Medical Examiner positively identified the two deceased persons from Texas County as Kelley and Butler.
The documents included in the motion for a consolidated hearing detail the roles of each of the five accused.
Grice stabbed and killed Butler and Cullum stabbed and killed Kelley and both accompanied the bodies to the burial site, which was a cow pasture leased by Cullum, according to court documents. The bodies were put into a freezer, which was in a previously dug hole in the pasture, which was arranged by Cullum in the days before the murder, according to court documents.
Grice put his clothing, a stun device purchased at Standard Supply by Adams and the knife he used in the hole at the burial site. His clothing found at the burial site contained both his and Butler’s DNA, according to the court document.
Cullum placed his clothing, including a pair of pants purchased by Adams in the hole at the burial site, which later were found to include his and Kelley’s DNA, according to the court document.
“Adams, in part, purchased the burner phones from Wal-mart which were used by the conspirators to communicate. She purchased the stun devices...She purchased the yellow straps that were placed around the freezer containing the bodies of Butler and Kelley at Tractor Supply. She purchased the pants that Cullum put in the burial site. Adams hated and despised Butler and wanted her dead,” the court document noted.
Cole and Cora Twombly acted as the lookouts on the day of the murders and, according to the documents, confided in their teen daughter in hopes of receiving an alibi for the morning of the murders.
On Wednesday the State, in its motion document, argued they were only seeking to join the cases for the preliminary hearing, not for trial. They also argued that the young witness, the Twombly’s daughter, would have to travel to Oklahoma 10 separate times to testify. “Such a result is unconscionable,” the document noted.