Who is the LONG ISLAND SERIAL KILLER? *ARREST JULY 2023*

long island.jpg


Who is the Long Island serial killer? This is a general discussion thread about this terrifying case.


MEMBER'S ONLY DISCUSSION/DOCUMENTS:
https://www.crimewatchers.net/threa...other-sensitive-information.3498/#post-226869
 
Last edited:
Of note to me in the presser is he couldn't say that with Valerie Mack. They don't know or at least that's what it sounded like...
Oh really? I haven't had time yet today to listen to the presser. I posted it for everyone then had to do some admin (financial) paperwork - boring but necessary sh!t. I'll have to check the timeline again re Valerie And Karen.
 
Here's the link just to the PC. I haven't watched yet. But all the relatives enter about 6.43 then it begins. 39 minutes long in total.



If you haven't watched it still, do so. There are some nuggets... He seems pressured, rushed but still there are some things in it.
 
I found the whole "drain thing" Interesting as well as I was unaware of it
I don't think I was either. It stood out. We don't get news often on this one but when we do, there are generally new tidbits. Now another charge of murder.

These girls went through sheer he77 and terror. I try not to think of that but it hits on occasion. Women I guess, not girls.
 
Yeah I am happy Valerie's family now has justice on the way, but I will say I am waiting on Vergata big time. If that story pans out, then it changes everything re Asa imo.

Presser had a lot of interesting things. I do wish they'd learn in this day and age to be able to hear reporter's questions.

A lot re if things happened in the house was interesting as well. Thanks for sharing it or I wouldn't have likely seen it.
You're welcome. I kept seeing it in the articles but it wouldnt let me watch without getting rid of my ad blocker, which i never do. So i had to search until i found a copy that was easily available to watch. Checked the start and end time for everyone, but by then, i ran out of time and had to get something productive done today, so still haven't yet watched it myself. It is getting late here and i don't want nightmares.
 
I think he held some of them at his house for a few days, at least. I don't know which ones, but a few. So his wife could be involved.
I'm not against that thought at the moment. I have definitely not released her from my thoughts of such a possibility.

And in the presser, Tierney cannot say if the kids or she were there with Mack, or gone. That was pretty notable to me.

And since it is now charged, I'd bet they tried to determine that.

The presser is worth a watch if you haven't.

Not every single thing is of interest, lots of kudos and thanks, but there are nuggets.

As far as holding them too at the home, that's what bothers me. They use the probable going missing date but it does not mean they didn't die days later, etc.

His manifesto or planning guide or whatever one calls it, can't think of it right now, has him saying to take time for more "fun" or some such. Get some rest, to me it sounded like keep them alive longer to torture and the ones after he wrote that and i don't recall the date but it was years back, I can't even imagine what he put them through and don't want to.

And God does he look like a smug arrogant azz.
 
Yeah i noticed that and immediately thought of the hot tub. :vomit:🤮🤮
Yeah I never put together as you did the hot tub and basement door outside. I was more looking to try to tell if it was a hot tub or not, but I did think of whether they entertained in it, more the swinging and stuff....
 
Below are the ones that haven't been charged yet, so I think it could be Karen or Valerie that gets charged next. What do you think?

Karen Vergata missing Feb 14th 1996
Alicia Reynolds, 2nd March 1996, VA
"Peaches" discovered in 1997
(Baby "Peaches" discovered April 2011)
***Valerie Mack Spring/Summer 2000
Jodie Brewer, 19, Aug 2006, Las Vegas
Kim Raffo, 35, 21st Nov 2006
Tracy Ann Roberts, 23, Oct 2006
Barbara Breidor, 42, Nov 2006
Molly Dilts, 19, Nov 2006
(Above four victims from Atlantic City )
Shannan Gilbert May 2010 disc Dec 2011
Asian male discovered April 2011
Aaliyah Bell, Rock Hill, SC Nov 2014

*** RH declared a POI in June 2023.

Bringing forward and removing Valerie from this list. That's taken 18 months to charge him with her murder.

Am also adding Tanya Rush (2008) and Cherries (2007) to this list now.

Updated list Dec 2024
Karen Vergata missing Feb 14th 1996
Alicia Reynolds, 2nd March 1996, VA
"Peaches" discovered in 1997
(Baby "Peaches" discovered April 2011)
Jodie Brewer, 19, Aug 2006, Las Vegas
Kim Raffo, 35, 21st Nov 2006
Tracy Ann Roberts, 23, Oct 2006
Barbara Breidor, 42, Nov 2006
Molly Dilts, 19, Nov 2006
(Above four victims from Atlantic City )
Cherries (2007)
Tanya Rush (2008)
Shannan Gilbert May 2010 disc Dec 2011
Asian male discovered April 2011
Aaliyah Bell, Rock Hill, SC Nov 2014
 
So far, the only one where there is talk of her being there when a victim was also there is Karen Vergata in the 90's when she was supposedly seen by a witness who signed an affidavit to that effect, so i do agree on that one. It will be interesting if and when they have enough evidence to charge him for Karen's murder. I think they are going only for those where they have a definite DNA link ATM.
That's why I want to know on that one more than any. Of course I care about them all but it would indicate a likely knowledge by Asa.

In the presser, it was a daughter's hair here it seems, or likely, in Mack I mean. And he does talk of the likelihoods and percentages and this better testing, etc.

It has to be hard to go back on very old purposely messed up cases and get evidence. But unless I'm wrong, so far is there not a hair or some such in every single one they have charged?
 
Oh really? I haven't had time yet today to listen to the presser. I posted it for everyone then had to do some admin (financial) paperwork - boring but necessary sh!t. I'll have to check the timeline again re Valerie And Karen.
Yep. He couldn't say if they were gone or not. Asa and the family.

A lot of it is thanking the team and all of that, the others that helped, etc. but there are some nuggets in it.

Isn't that a pain? I am here sitting waiting for something from the doctor that I need to provide today. Paperwork I mean. With a deadline. I feel for you. At the worst of times, that's what has to be dealt with.
 
Oh really? I haven't had time yet today to listen to the presser. I posted it for everyone then had to do some admin (financial) paperwork - boring but necessary sh!t. I'll have to check the timeline again re Valerie And Karen.
Kind of what I do sometimes and I get it. I will post something I see but haven't had time to watch yet so others have it even if I can't watch at the moment.

And if I do watch, I try to tell others if worth it or not. Etc.

Colby has had quite a few shows recently but I haven't got the chance to link. In Daybell. Some pretty raw, seen a couple, not all.

Kohberger seems to have some new news, haven't been able to follow that either.

Or link. Scott is keeping up with it. Reisch. I hope to see it, but just can't right now.
 
You're welcome. I kept seeing it in the articles but it wouldnt let me watch without getting rid of my ad blocker, which i never do. So i had to search until i found a copy that was easily available to watch. Checked the start and end time for everyone, but by then, i ran out of time and had to get something productive done today, so still haven't yet watched it myself. It is getting late here and i don't want nightmares.
I don't blame you. Yes it was a good link. As you know I don't watch or can't all either but try to link for others but did watch that waiting for a not on time by any means phone call.

There is a lot of thanking and probably the political ensuring all are noted that are helping with it, and the team but then it got to questions which like most pressers, one can't usually hear the question, just the answer.

And he simply could not say if the family was home or not. AND this one seemed to be the daughter's hair as the most likelihood. Talked some about this new stuff on science, my guess is they expect a challenge. It's worth a listen. There were a couple of other things but I forget at the moment. Those stood out to me though, mostly that they don't know if Mrs. CB and kids were home or not.
 
Oh, there will be more.I'm convinced there will be the one thing that really always upsets me is that if it was not for the vigorous search for shannan gilbert These girls would never have been found and shannan Is always forgotten in all of this and never mentioned. I've said it on here before and I will always say it. I will never ever believe that girl ran out of her pants.... she was murdered... She was running from somebody.I do understand and I am well aware she had mental health issues. But as mental as anybody can be when you are running for your life you are running for your life... Running out of your shoes losing your shoes when running for your life. I get it, but no one that I've ever heard of has ran out of their pants. Not skinny jeans not leggings not tight fitting clothing like that...
Totally agree that Shannon was murdered. Never have to worry about convincing me of that. And she IS ignored.

The stuff they try to feed us to this day in that one, I just can't even find words for. I don't even assume she was murdered by this man and maybe that's the problem, covering for someone, or lawsuits or black eyes because they just won't even GO THERE.

The held 911 calls and fights over it for YEARS. I don't hear drugs in that at all, I know sheer terror. And searching for her only when pushed imo led to finding all these others so it COULD be same guy with others, hard to say.

It upsets me too, and I want that known.

Never will I talk differently, and yeah falling out of her jeans. Far more than that thought that does not add up.
 
Bringing forward and removing Valerie from this list. That's taken 18 months to charge him with her murder.

Am also adding Tanya Rush (2008) and Cherries (2007) to this list now.

Updated list Dec 2024
Karen Vergata missing Feb 14th 1996
Alicia Reynolds, 2nd March 1996, VA
"Peaches" discovered in 1997
(Baby "Peaches" discovered April 2011)
Jodie Brewer, 19, Aug 2006, Las Vegas
Kim Raffo, 35, 21st Nov 2006
Tracy Ann Roberts, 23, Oct 2006
Barbara Breidor, 42, Nov 2006
Molly Dilts, 19, Nov 2006
(Above four victims from Atlantic City )
Cherries (2007)
Tanya Rush (2008)
Shannan Gilbert May 2010 disc Dec 2011
Asian male discovered April 2011
Aaliyah Bell, Rock Hill, SC Nov 2014
As much as I hate the time between charges and news other than about what his wife is up to lol, they are being methodical it seems and trying to do it right. The way defenses are these days and how far it has went, I can't blame them. Appeals, etc. And the entire investigation and corrupt sh*t has been compromised from the start.

I don't know why he is pleading not guilty, they have so much, other than maybe ol' Happy told him there is no butter in prison... But then of course don't they all do that and SKs love the limelight or seem to.
 
Wow this Mary Murphy article has a lot of info from today.



Valerie Mack (formerly knows as Jane Doe #6

Valerie Mack (formerly known as "Jane Doe #6")

Valerie Mack's parents walked slowly, escorted by investigators from the Suffolk County District Attorney's Office, as they left a courtroom in Riverhead, Long Island.

They were nearly two hundred miles from their home in southern New Jersey.

Edwin and Joanne Mack were finally emerging from the shadows in a horrifying serial killer case, following the relatives of other Gilgo Beach victims down a long hallway.



Valerie Mack was known for twenty years as Jane Doe # 6, until her identity was announced on May 28, 2020. This was three years before architect Rex Heuermann was arrested and accused of being the Long Island serial killer, known as LISK.



On Tuesday, December 17, 2024, Valerie Mack's name was officially included among LISK victims, when a superseding indictment was unsealed inside the 4th floor courtroom of Judge Timothy Mazzei. It accused Heuermann of this seventh murder in the Gilgo Beach investigation. But with his hands shackled behind his back, Heuermann loudly proclaimed, "Your Honor, I am not guilty of ANY of these charges." From where I was sitting, very close to a large number of victims' relatives, one woman responded under her breath, "F--k you!"



Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

The 20-page bail application released Tuesday by Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney, part of a request to keep Heuermann remanded before trial, contained more, shocking information about the LISK case. Valerie Mack was one of two dismembered victims found in Manorville. The documents revealed that one hair found on Valerie Mack's left wrist was tied by nuclear DNA testing to Rex Heuermann's daughter, Victoria, who would have been 3 or 4 years old in 2000 at the time of Mack's murder. Once again, prosecutors believe household transfer of family members' DNA turned up on the body of a LISK victim.







Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney announces 7th indictment against accused serial killer Rex Heuermann, with parents of Valerie Mack standing behind him. December 17, 2024.



Prosecutors said in their papers that Valerie Mack, 24, was last seen in Port Republic, New Jersey near the home of her parents', who had adopted her out of the foster care system. She gave birth to a son at age 17 and once lived with the child's father in Wildwood, New Jersey. She was known to be a sex worker who frequented the Philadelphia and Atlantic City areas.



The District Attorney said that on 11/19/2000, a dog walking with hunters in the woods of Manorville, Long Island alerted the group to a black plastic bag wrapped with duct tape. Inside the bag, additional plastic bags contained human remains. The female victim was decapitated. Both of her hands had been severed from her body above the wrists. Part of her right leg was cut off, mid-calf. Authorities later learned this portion of Valerie Mack's leg contained a tattoo with the name of her young son. Pathologists believe the victim was dead two to eight weeks when she was discovered.



Investigators also revealed that when they extracted information from Rex Heuermann's electronic devices, they found his home IP address was used to access Gilgonews.com on May 23, 2020, a Suffolk County police department website that was going to reveal Mack's identity. She was publicly identified five days later.



Prosecutors said Valerie Mack was tied up in rope and alleged that in the months leading up to her 2000 disappearance, Rex Heuermann was accessing pornographic images online that included breast mutilation and the tying up of women with rope.



The bail application made many comparisons between Valerie Mack's killing and the 2003 dismemberment murder of LISK victim, Jessica Taylor, whose torso was also discovered near Mill Road in Manorville. A forensic anthropologist at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner in New York City "analyzed the cut bones of both victims, which led to the conclusion that a hand-powered saw, with similar blade widths, (was) utilized in the dismemberments of both Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack." The documents also noted the garbage bags found at both dump sites were similar in "color, seal location, knots, perforations, size."



Of particular interest to many reporters were magazine and newspaper articles about the serial killer investigation allegedly found in Heuermann's Manhattan office and his Long Island home.



Shortly after Heuermann's July 2023 arrest, agents from the Gilgo Homicide Task Force said they found a 2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case in his Manhattan office. The article was titled, "Bodies on the Beach."

Also in 2023, they reported finding a New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, inside the basement vault of Heuermann's Massapequa Park home. During a follow up search in 2024, investigators said they discovered a New York Post newspaper article about the Valerie Mack and Jessica Taylor murders inside Heuermann's primary bedroom. They concluded in their affidavit that these keepsake articles "indicates the Defendant's attempts to remind himself of the events that occurred through the murders of each victim, revealing Rex A. Heuermann's utter lack of (dis)regard or remorse for his actions or the victims."



People Magazine 2016


New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016



2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case found in Heuermann's Manhattan office.

New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, found in Heuermann's home.



There was also a Newsday article included in the bail application, a reference to the 1993 story about a woman's body found in the woods of North Sea, a hamlet in Southampton. The victim was Sandra Costilla of Queens. DA Tierney charged Rex Heuermann with the murders of both Sandra Costilla and Jessica Taylor back in June 2024.

Newsday article 1993

Newsday Article, 1993.

There were many references in Tuesday's proceedings to the HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer that allegedly served as a "blueprint" for the murders. Prosecutors believe the defendant generally preferred smaller victims and pointed out the document's notation that SMALL IS GOOD.



The planning document also made reference to foam drain cleaner as a supply the alleged killer would need. In the latest documents, prosecutors said Heuermann reached out to a plumber in October 2000 and later paid $283.83 to another company to check his "mainline" drain.



HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer


HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer.



On April 4, 2011, Valerie Mack's skull, hands, and right foot were discovered along the north side of Ocean Parkway, just east of Gilgo Beach. This was about four months after a police dog made the initial discovery of the 'Gilgo Four' victims, women Heuermann is also accused of killing. Valerie Mack's remains were found close to a female toddler who's been linked, by DNA, to the Gilgo victim known as Peaches. Heuermann has not been charged in the Peaches case.



Map detailing where 6 victims were found. Courtesy of Suffolk County Police.
 
Wow this Mary Murphy article has a lot of info from today.



Valerie Mack (formerly knows as Jane Doe #6

Valerie Mack (formerly known as "Jane Doe #6")

Valerie Mack's parents walked slowly, escorted by investigators from the Suffolk County District Attorney's Office, as they left a courtroom in Riverhead, Long Island.

They were nearly two hundred miles from their home in southern New Jersey.

Edwin and Joanne Mack were finally emerging from the shadows in a horrifying serial killer case, following the relatives of other Gilgo Beach victims down a long hallway.



Valerie Mack was known for twenty years as Jane Doe # 6, until her identity was announced on May 28, 2020. This was three years before architect Rex Heuermann was arrested and accused of being the Long Island serial killer, known as LISK.



On Tuesday, December 17, 2024, Valerie Mack's name was officially included among LISK victims, when a superseding indictment was unsealed inside the 4th floor courtroom of Judge Timothy Mazzei. It accused Heuermann of this seventh murder in the Gilgo Beach investigation. But with his hands shackled behind his back, Heuermann loudly proclaimed, "Your Honor, I am not guilty of ANY of these charges." From where I was sitting, very close to a large number of victims' relatives, one woman responded under her breath, "F--k you!"



Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

The 20-page bail application released Tuesday by Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney, part of a request to keep Heuermann remanded before trial, contained more, shocking information about the LISK case. Valerie Mack was one of two dismembered victims found in Manorville. The documents revealed that one hair found on Valerie Mack's left wrist was tied by nuclear DNA testing to Rex Heuermann's daughter, Victoria, who would have been 3 or 4 years old in 2000 at the time of Mack's murder. Once again, prosecutors believe household transfer of family members' DNA turned up on the body of a LISK victim.







Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney announces 7th indictment against accused serial killer Rex Heuermann, with parents of Valerie Mack standing behind him. December 17, 2024.



Prosecutors said in their papers that Valerie Mack, 24, was last seen in Port Republic, New Jersey near the home of her parents', who had adopted her out of the foster care system. She gave birth to a son at age 17 and once lived with the child's father in Wildwood, New Jersey. She was known to be a sex worker who frequented the Philadelphia and Atlantic City areas.



The District Attorney said that on 11/19/2000, a dog walking with hunters in the woods of Manorville, Long Island alerted the group to a black plastic bag wrapped with duct tape. Inside the bag, additional plastic bags contained human remains. The female victim was decapitated. Both of her hands had been severed from her body above the wrists. Part of her right leg was cut off, mid-calf. Authorities later learned this portion of Valerie Mack's leg contained a tattoo with the name of her young son. Pathologists believe the victim was dead two to eight weeks when she was discovered.



Investigators also revealed that when they extracted information from Rex Heuermann's electronic devices, they found his home IP address was used to access Gilgonews.com on May 23, 2020, a Suffolk County police department website that was going to reveal Mack's identity. She was publicly identified five days later.



Prosecutors said Valerie Mack was tied up in rope and alleged that in the months leading up to her 2000 disappearance, Rex Heuermann was accessing pornographic images online that included breast mutilation and the tying up of women with rope.



The bail application made many comparisons between Valerie Mack's killing and the 2003 dismemberment murder of LISK victim, Jessica Taylor, whose torso was also discovered near Mill Road in Manorville. A forensic anthropologist at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner in New York City "analyzed the cut bones of both victims, which led to the conclusion that a hand-powered saw, with similar blade widths, (was) utilized in the dismemberments of both Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack." The documents also noted the garbage bags found at both dump sites were similar in "color, seal location, knots, perforations, size."



Of particular interest to many reporters were magazine and newspaper articles about the serial killer investigation allegedly found in Heuermann's Manhattan office and his Long Island home.



Shortly after Heuermann's July 2023 arrest, agents from the Gilgo Homicide Task Force said they found a 2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case in his Manhattan office. The article was titled, "Bodies on the Beach."

Also in 2023, they reported finding a New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, inside the basement vault of Heuermann's Massapequa Park home. During a follow up search in 2024, investigators said they discovered a New York Post newspaper article about the Valerie Mack and Jessica Taylor murders inside Heuermann's primary bedroom. They concluded in their affidavit that these keepsake articles "indicates the Defendant's attempts to remind himself of the events that occurred through the murders of each victim, revealing Rex A. Heuermann's utter lack of (dis)regard or remorse for his actions or the victims."



People Magazine 2016


New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016



2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case found in Heuermann's Manhattan office.

New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, found in Heuermann's home.



There was also a Newsday article included in the bail application, a reference to the 1993 story about a woman's body found in the woods of North Sea, a hamlet in Southampton. The victim was Sandra Costilla of Queens. DA Tierney charged Rex Heuermann with the murders of both Sandra Costilla and Jessica Taylor back in June 2024.

Newsday article 1993

Newsday Article, 1993.

There were many references in Tuesday's proceedings to the HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer that allegedly served as a "blueprint" for the murders. Prosecutors believe the defendant generally preferred smaller victims and pointed out the document's notation that SMALL IS GOOD.



The planning document also made reference to foam drain cleaner as a supply the alleged killer would need. In the latest documents, prosecutors said Heuermann reached out to a plumber in October 2000 and later paid $283.83 to another company to check his "mainline" drain.



HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer's computer


HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer.



On April 4, 2011, Valerie Mack's skull, hands, and right foot were discovered along the north side of Ocean Parkway, just east of Gilgo Beach. This was about four months after a police dog made the initial discovery of the 'Gilgo Four' victims, women Heuermann is also accused of killing. Valerie Mack's remains were found close to a female toddler who's been linked, by DNA, to the Gilgo victim known as Peaches. Heuermann has not been charged in the Peaches case.



Map detailing where 6 victims were found. Courtesy of Suffolk County Police.
Of course his attorney is going to challenge the reliability of the d n a evidence... They always do and it's torture For the families , all the court hearings that will have to be had it will drag it out.
Prosecution Appears to be doing the right thing.Being is careful and calculated as possible.And in a complicated case like this. With more victims possibly to come up they have to be.
 
Wow this Mary Murphy article has a lot of info from today.



Valerie Mack (formerly knows as Jane Doe #6

Valerie Mack (formerly known as "Jane Doe #6")

Valerie Mack's parents walked slowly, escorted by investigators from the Suffolk County District Attorney's Office, as they left a courtroom in Riverhead, Long Island.

They were nearly two hundred miles from their home in southern New Jersey.

Edwin and Joanne Mack were finally emerging from the shadows in a horrifying serial killer case, following the relatives of other Gilgo Beach victims down a long hallway.



Valerie Mack was known for twenty years as Jane Doe # 6, until her identity was announced on May 28, 2020. This was three years before architect Rex Heuermann was arrested and accused of being the Long Island serial killer, known as LISK.



On Tuesday, December 17, 2024, Valerie Mack's name was officially included among LISK victims, when a superseding indictment was unsealed inside the 4th floor courtroom of Judge Timothy Mazzei. It accused Heuermann of this seventh murder in the Gilgo Beach investigation. But with his hands shackled behind his back, Heuermann loudly proclaimed, "Your Honor, I am not guilty of ANY of these charges." From where I was sitting, very close to a large number of victims' relatives, one woman responded under her breath, "F--k you!"



Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

Rex Heuermann in court December 17, 2024. Pool Photo: James Carbone.

The 20-page bail application released Tuesday by Suffolk County District Attorney Raymond Tierney, part of a request to keep Heuermann remanded before trial, contained more, shocking information about the LISK case. Valerie Mack was one of two dismembered victims found in Manorville. The documents revealed that one hair found on Valerie Mack's left wrist was tied by nuclear DNA testing to Rex Heuermann's daughter, Victoria, who would have been 3 or 4 years old in 2000 at the time of Mack's murder. Once again, prosecutors believe household transfer of family members' DNA turned up on the body of a LISK victim.







Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney announces 7th indictment against accused serial killer Rex Heuermann, with parents of Valerie Mack standing behind him. December 17, 2024.



Prosecutors said in their papers that Valerie Mack, 24, was last seen in Port Republic, New Jersey near the home of her parents', who had adopted her out of the foster care system. She gave birth to a son at age 17 and once lived with the child's father in Wildwood, New Jersey. She was known to be a sex worker who frequented the Philadelphia and Atlantic City areas.



The District Attorney said that on 11/19/2000, a dog walking with hunters in the woods of Manorville, Long Island alerted the group to a black plastic bag wrapped with duct tape. Inside the bag, additional plastic bags contained human remains. The female victim was decapitated. Both of her hands had been severed from her body above the wrists. Part of her right leg was cut off, mid-calf. Authorities later learned this portion of Valerie Mack's leg contained a tattoo with the name of her young son. Pathologists believe the victim was dead two to eight weeks when she was discovered.



Investigators also revealed that when they extracted information from Rex Heuermann's electronic devices, they found his home IP address was used to access Gilgonews.com on May 23, 2020, a Suffolk County police department website that was going to reveal Mack's identity. She was publicly identified five days later.



Prosecutors said Valerie Mack was tied up in rope and alleged that in the months leading up to her 2000 disappearance, Rex Heuermann was accessing pornographic images online that included breast mutilation and the tying up of women with rope.



The bail application made many comparisons between Valerie Mack's killing and the 2003 dismemberment murder of LISK victim, Jessica Taylor, whose torso was also discovered near Mill Road in Manorville. A forensic anthropologist at the Office of Chief Medical Examiner in New York City "analyzed the cut bones of both victims, which led to the conclusion that a hand-powered saw, with similar blade widths, (was) utilized in the dismemberments of both Jessica Taylor and Valerie Mack." The documents also noted the garbage bags found at both dump sites were similar in "color, seal location, knots, perforations, size."



Of particular interest to many reporters were magazine and newspaper articles about the serial killer investigation allegedly found in Heuermann's Manhattan office and his Long Island home.



Shortly after Heuermann's July 2023 arrest, agents from the Gilgo Homicide Task Force said they found a 2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case in his Manhattan office. The article was titled, "Bodies on the Beach."

Also in 2023, they reported finding a New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, inside the basement vault of Heuermann's Massapequa Park home. During a follow up search in 2024, investigators said they discovered a New York Post newspaper article about the Valerie Mack and Jessica Taylor murders inside Heuermann's primary bedroom. They concluded in their affidavit that these keepsake articles "indicates the Defendant's attempts to remind himself of the events that occurred through the murders of each victim, revealing Rex A. Heuermann's utter lack of (dis)regard or remorse for his actions or the victims."



People Magazine 2016


New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016



2016 People magazine issue about the Long Island Serial Killer case found in Heuermann's Manhattan office.

New York Magazine cover story about the case, written in 2016, found in Heuermann's home.



There was also a Newsday article included in the bail application, a reference to the 1993 story about a woman's body found in the woods of North Sea, a hamlet in Southampton. The victim was Sandra Costilla of Queens. DA Tierney charged Rex Heuermann with the murders of both Sandra Costilla and Jessica Taylor back in June 2024.

Newsday article 1993

Newsday Article, 1993.

There were many references in Tuesday's proceedings to the HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer that allegedly served as a "blueprint" for the murders. Prosecutors believe the defendant generally preferred smaller victims and pointed out the document's notation that SMALL IS GOOD.



The planning document also made reference to foam drain cleaner as a supply the alleged killer would need. In the latest documents, prosecutors said Heuermann reached out to a plumber in October 2000 and later paid $283.83 to another company to check his "mainline" drain.



HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer's computer


HK Planning Document extracted from Rex Heuermann's computer.



On April 4, 2011, Valerie Mack's skull, hands, and right foot were discovered along the north side of Ocean Parkway, just east of Gilgo Beach. This was about four months after a police dog made the initial discovery of the 'Gilgo Four' victims, women Heuermann is also accused of killing. Valerie Mack's remains were found close to a female toddler who's been linked, by DNA, to the Gilgo victim known as Peaches. Heuermann has not been charged in the Peaches case.



Map detailing where 6 victims were found. Courtesy of Suffolk County Police.
Man you sure find the articles. This is bone chilling and I did not even go into the link, just read what was here.

And he seems SO SMUG.

These poor families. And the poor "girls".

They seem to let a bit more out each time. Probably to make their probable cause or charge, whatever it's called.

This had quite the details.
 
Man you sure find the articles. This is bone chilling and I did not even go into the link, just read what was here.

And he seems SO SMUG.

These poor families. And the poor "girls".

They seem to let a bit more out each time. Probably to make their probable cause or charge, whatever it's called.

This had quite the details.
I pretty much copied the whole article I think, it was so good.
 
Man you sure find the articles. This is bone chilling and I did not even go into the link, just read what was here.

And he seems SO SMUG.

These poor families. And the poor "girls".

They seem to let a bit more out each time. Probably to make their probable cause or charge, whatever it's called.

This had quite the details.
This guy is just one really disturbing dude.I mean all those articles hidden all over the place in his office and his home just ewww He is a sicko
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,044
Messages
247,514
Members
992
Latest member
lifeofthespider
Back
Top Bottom