Oxford, MI School Shooting *Ethan Crumbley GUILTY PLEA* - *Mom & Dad GUILTY of manslaughter*

Last edited by a moderator:
Crumbley remains in jail, attorney says he's competent for the Miller Hearing
Appearing by Zoom Friday morning, a judge determined Ethan Crumbley will remain in the Oakland County Jail.

Oakland County Circuit Court Judge Kwame Rowe says this was the last monthly hearing.

Next month on July 27, 2023, Crumbley will have a Miller Hearing.

A Miller Hearing is required for anyone under the age of 17; it's a pre-sentencing hearing.

The judge will take into consideration the circumstances and determine if he will face a life sentence.

Oakland County Assistant Prosecuting Attorney Marc Keast mentioned Friday, that the prosecutor's office was made aware of concerning behavior by Crumbley at the jail.

Keast did not provide additional details.

Both Deborah McKelvy, who is the legal representative for Crumbley, and his attorney Paulette Loftin say they believe Crumbley is competent for the Miller Hearing.
 

Oxford High School shooting: New evidence reveals James, Jennifer Crumbley's 'consciousness of guilt'​

A case filing reveals more details that the prosecution says prove Oxford High School shooter Ethan Crumbley's parents were negligent ahead of the crime.


Previously, the prosecution shared messages between Jennifer and Ethan, as well as between Jennifer and James, that shows Ethan had discussed his mental state with his parents, and they were concerned about it at least eight months before the shooting.

The new court filing dives deeper into that accusation, with more messages between Jennifer and James showing they discussed Ethan's mental state in March 2021.

In an exchange on March 8, 2021, Jennifer messaged James saying she was "freaking out" because she couldn't reach Ethan after school. She also was frustrated with James not picking Ethan up "because he’s upset and I don’t want him to do anything stupid."

The prosecution argues that this shows the parents were aware of their son's mental distress.

The filing also reveals that Jennifer allegedly told an interviewer after the shooting that she "didn’t even look at them closely," referring to disturbing photos Ethan drew on a math test ahead of the shooting. She also allegedly said, "My biggest fear was that he was gonna turn the gun on himself."

"Such fear only highlights the foreseeability of their son using the murder weapon—whether it be on himself or others," prosecutors wrote.

In the new filing, prosecutors also noted that the parents took the receipt for the gun James allegedly purchased for Ethan when they fled after the shooting. They had the receipt when caught in Detroit, prosecutors say.

"Defendants’ flight and the taking of the receipt for the murder weapon during such flight provide an inference of their consciousness of guilt," prosecutors wrote.


The defense attorneys have argued that whatever the parents did might have been considered bad parenting, but it was not the cause of the deaths, and they want the case thrown out.
 

Posted at 1:32 PM, Jul 10, 2023
and last updated 3:05 PM, Jul 10, 2023

(WXYZ) — Ethan Crumbley is asking the court to dismiss the life without parole condition that is connected to his guilty pleas in the Oxford High School shootings.

Crumbley asked to dismiss the condition in a motion to the court. He is also asking for permission to dress in street clothes for his upcoming hearing. He is next due in court for a motion hearing on July 12.

Crumbleypleaded guilty to 24 charges, including one count of terrorism and four counts of first-degree murder, in last year's deadly Oxford High School shooting, in October.
 
Judge denies Ethan Crumbley's request to have life without parole sentence dismissed
Last week, Crumbley requested for his life without parole sentence to be removed, to wear street clothes to the Miller hearing, and to keep witnesses of the shooting from testifying at the Miller hearing.

The Miller hearing will consider Crumbley's age, along with evidence, in determining if the teen should be sentenced to life without parole.

All three of his requests were denied Tuesday, July 18.

Crumbley's Miller hearing is scheduled for Thursday, July 27.
 

Ethan Crumbley doesn't want bodies of Oxford school shooting victims shown at hearing​

With his last wish list denied, school shooter Ethan Crumbley has made more requests of the judge who will sentence him, including that images of his victims' bodies not be shown at an upcoming hearing that will help determine his punishment.

Crumbley, who murdered four students and injured seven others, also is trying to block the prosecution from showing security footage of the 2021 mass shooting he carried out at Oxford High School. His lawyer also wants to bar a video of him torturing a bird.

The prosecution intends to show all of this next week at Crumbley's so-called Miller hearing, a mandatory procedure during which the judge will determine whether a life without parole sentence is appropriate for his crimes.

"The people intend to do this in a courtroom packed full of family members of victims, and the media. This court should preclude the people from doing so because the proposed exhibits are not relevant to any of the Miller factors, and are needlessly prejudicial and inflammatory," Crumbley's attorney, Paulette Michel Loftin wrote in a court filing this week, adding the prosecution is "determined to introduce graphic evidence of the crime itself."

But this evidence, Loftin argues, is not relevant. Moreover, she stressed, her client has already pleaded guilty to his crimes and does not dispute what the prosecution intends to show.

"It can only be that the people are simply hoping to shock this court into ignoring all the Miller factors," Loftin writes.

If the judge does, however, allow the prosecution to show these exhibits, Loftin asked that the judge review them privately in his chambers, not an open courtroom.
 

Judge says no again to Ethan Crumbley, denies three more requests​

The blows keep coming for school shooter Ethan Crumbley, whose lawyers keep making requests of the judge who will sentence him.

The judge keeps saying no.

The latest setback came Thursday, with Oakland County Judge Kwame Rowe denying Crumbley's latest request to prohibit blurred images of his victims' bodies from being shown at an upcoming hearing involving his potential punishment. The defense team also asked that security footage of the 2021 mass shooting at Oxford High School not be shown in court, nor a video of Crumbley torturing a bird.

But Rowe is letting the crime scene footage and images of the victims in as he will be the one evaluating the evidence at the so-called Miller hearing — a special proceeding during which the judge will determine whether a life without parole sentence is appropriate for Crumbley.

"The court notes the sensitive nature of the crime scene footage and photos and its impact it may have on victims and/or their family. The court is not insensitive to this impact," Rowe writes in his opinion. "However, the court has not been provided any legal authority to suggest that this evidence, which this court has never seen before, should be reviewed (privately) and not in open court."

As for the video of Crumbley torturing the bird, the judge noted he has already seen that before. So if prosecutors want to introduce it at the Miller hearing, he will view it privately.
 

Judge says no again to Ethan Crumbley, denies three more requests​

The blows keep coming for school shooter Ethan Crumbley, whose lawyers keep making requests of the judge who will sentence him.

The judge keeps saying no.

The latest setback came Thursday, with Oakland County Judge Kwame Rowe denying Crumbley's latest request to prohibit blurred images of his victims' bodies from being shown at an upcoming hearing involving his potential punishment. The defense team also asked that security footage of the 2021 mass shooting at Oxford High School not be shown in court, nor a video of Crumbley torturing a bird.

But Rowe is letting the crime scene footage and images of the victims in as he will be the one evaluating the evidence at the so-called Miller hearing — a special proceeding during which the judge will determine whether a life without parole sentence is appropriate for Crumbley.

"The court notes the sensitive nature of the crime scene footage and photos and its impact it may have on victims and/or their family. The court is not insensitive to this impact," Rowe writes in his opinion. "However, the court has not been provided any legal authority to suggest that this evidence, which this court has never seen before, should be reviewed (privately) and not in open court."

As for the video of Crumbley torturing the bird, the judge noted he has already seen that before. So if prosecutors want to introduce it at the Miller hearing, he will view it privately.
GOOD!!! A judge not coddling this POS. An animal torturer too. I'd have a bigger problem seeing that. It was a video. Nope. I've seen alot dead people images. The worst of the worst. It is disturbing. I don't want ANYTHING to go in his favor! Do the families want to show the violence. Personally I would. To show the brutality. But I understand if they don't. I can't imagine what they are going through. They could leave the courtroom during that phase. IMO The pictures would be the final nail in his coffin.
 

Michigan school shooter Ethan Crumbley recorded audio saying ‘I’m gonna have so much fun’ the night before the carnage, evidence shows​

Ethan Crumbley recorded audio saying, “I am going to be the next school shooter,” the night before killing four students and wounding seven others in a mass shooting at Michigan’s Oxford High School in 2021.

Prosecutors played the audio of two video clips Thursday during a hearing to determine whether he should spend the rest of his life in prison without the possibility of parole.

“My name is Ethan Crumbley, age 15, and I am going to be the next school shooter,” he is heard saying on the audio played in court. “I’ve thought about this a lot. I can’t stop thinking about it. But it’s constantly in my head.”

Crumbley appeared to look down at the defense table as the audio was played.

In the second audio file played at the hearing Crumbley said, “I’m gonna have so much fun tomorrow.”

In the recordings, Crumbley talks about the decline of his life, his hate for the world and the need to teach others “a lesson” by shooting up a school.

“I will walk behind someone, and I will shoot a bullet into their skull. And that’s the first victim,” he said. “I’m gonna open fire on everyone in the hallway … I will try to hit as many people as I can. I will reload, and I will find people hiding. I want to teach them a lesson of how they are wrong, of how they are being brainwashed.”


Earlier Thursday, Crumbley’s journal entries were read in court.

Crumbley successfully executed many of the plans he outlined in the journal, Keast told the court.

One entry said: “I want to shoot up the school so f**king badly.”

“The first victim has to be a pretty girl with a future so she can suffer just like me,” Crumbley wrote in another.

The first shooting victim was a female student, Phoebe Arthur, the lieutenant confirmed.

“I will continue shooting people until police breach the building,” Crumbley wrote. “I will then surrender to them and plead guilty to life in prison.”

In one journal entry, Crumbley wrote about not having food because of his parents’ financial struggles.

“This morning, I woke up to my mom having one of her worst rants about how we have no money and can’t pay the bills. This just furthers my desire to shoot up the school or do something else. I have no happiness or optimism left in me as I am a burden to my parents,” Crumbley wrote.

Earlier Thursday, prosecutors played surveillance video of the shooting with no audio. Several family members tearfully watched the video.


Crumbley’s premeditation ahead of the shooting and propensity for violence are among the reasons he should receive a life sentence, Oakland County Prosecutor Karen McDonald said in her opening statement.

Crumbley’s attorney, Paulette Loftin, said the defense will show Crumbley is not “irreparably corrupt” and should be sentenced to a term of years in prison.


The hearing resumes Friday morning.

MORE AT LINK
 

Oxford parents fed up with school board, anxious for district’s information on shooting​

Lack of information from the school board about what happened during and before the tragic Oxford High School shooting in 2021 has been at the center of ongoing anger and frustration in the district.

Parents have been criticizing the district for providing little information about what happened on and what led up to the Nov. 30, 2021, shooting, in which four students were murdered and seven other people were injured.

Going back and forth for months, the school board has declined multiple offers from the Michigan attorney general to conduct an investigation after the fact. Eventually, the board was pressured into hiring an outside firm to conduct an investigation -- but those results aren’t expected until at least this fall.

“All we want to know is what Tate’s last day looked like,” said Buck Myre, father of Tate Myre, a student murdered in the shooting.

When a pre-sentencing hearing began for the Oxford shooter last month, Tate Myre’s parents were in attendance, listening to days of disturbing testimony regarding the shooter. The grieving parents initially did not want to watch videos of the shooting captured on surveillance cameras inside the school. They planned to walk out of the courtroom when the videos played.

But when the moment came, the mother and father decided to watch the footage that showed the Oxford shooter kill their child. Buck Myre said they had no choice but to watch the horrific videos.

“We were forced to watch it, because we don’t have one answer for that day,” Buck Myre told the school board during a recent meeting. “You guys made us watch it.

“Tate had a pulse; he heard her; he didn’t die alone. It took us one year and nine months to hear that,” Buck Myre said, referencing the witness testimony of an assistant school principal present during the shooting.

Tate Myre’s dad has made it painfully clear the lack of information about what happened, and why it happened, haunts him and the rest of his family. The two-year anniversary of the tragic mass shooting is quickly approaching, and community members still eagerly await information.

“It’s been 21 months, 616 days today -- that’s how long the victims’ families, and this community, have been waiting for answers,” a community member said during the board meeting.

Details about the shooter and the shooting have slowly been revealed over the last year and a half in courtrooms and court documents. But, with allegations against school staff and administrators accused of not doing enough to help prevent the shooting, the community wants answers from the district itself.

The district has promised to provide an independent audit of the tragic shooting and the days leading up to it. Those results may come as soon as early fall. But, with the community’s fundamental distrust of how the district has handled this process, it’s unknown if the parents will even accept what’s in the report.
 

Miller hearing for Oxford school shooter Ethan Crumbley enters fourth week​

A pre-sentencing hearing resumes this week for the teen who killed four classmates during a shooting rampage at Oxford High School in 2021.
 

Michigan Supreme Court refuses to hear case of James and Jennifer Crumbley​

The Michigan Supreme Court made history Friday in letting the unprecedented charges stick against James and Jennifer Crumbley, the parents of the Oxford school shooter who must now stand trial for their alleged roles in the deaths of four students murdered by their son in 2021.

The Crumbleys are the first parents in America charged in a mass school shooting as prosecutors seek to hold them criminally liable for buying their son the gun that he used in the massacre, and, for never telling the school about the weapon when they were summoned over his troubling behavior.

The parents, who are facing involuntary manslaughter charges, have been fighting for two years to get the charges dismissed. Their final appeal was before the Michigan Supreme Court, which after seven months of receiving the request, opted not to hear their case.

In a one-paragraph order released early Friday morning, the state's highest court wrote: " … it is denied, because we are not persuaded that the question should be reviewed by this court."

Neither side can comment on the latest ruling as there is a gag order that prohibits both the defense and prosecution from publicly speaking about this case.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,036
Messages
245,550
Members
984
Latest member
Flukeenz
Back
Top Bottom