Who is the LONG ISLAND SERIAL KILLER? *ARREST JULY 2023*

long island.jpg


Who is the Long Island serial killer? This is a general discussion thread about this terrifying case.


MEMBER'S ONLY DISCUSSION/DOCUMENTS:
https://www.crimewatchers.net/threa...other-sensitive-information.3498/#post-226869
 
Last edited:
Yeah, I think they have to work on identifying them further in order to trace last movements etc and then see if they advertised on Craig's List or similar.
Yeah even knowing they were sex workers when it isn't known who they were is impossible. I wonder if they do or have a clue. It was surprising they knew who Vergata was and held it after finding out. I mean I get things for investigative strategy but how would identification have alerted CB they were onto him especially with one hey haven't attributed to hi...
 
Because CB never chucked sh*t away I have a feeling they found the phone bills with alias names at his home for the burner phones but I am not sure about that. I just remember reading something. Does that ring a bell with you?
(LOL phone/ring a bell )

Also, wasn't he advertising on Craig's list too at one time? 🤮

This link gives me a reminder and I remember the lovely selfie he took presumably for his Craig's List entry.

The article also reminds me they caught him putting credit on one of his burner phones and also tracked his burner phones from the calls to victims' families.

Yeah I don't think he quit and also they clearly felt he was heating up again. So was it down by mom or elsewhere where he had homes he filled his sick killing needs in between........
 
Yeah even knowing they were sex workers when it isn't known who they were is impossible. I wonder if they do or have a clue. It was surprising they knew who Vergata was and held it after finding out. I mean I get things for investigative strategy but how would identification have alerted CB they were onto him especially with one hey haven't attributed to hi...
I wonder if he had them all written down somewhere with names and souvenirs and I also wonder if he ever used regulars more than once. It is strange none have come forward except for those few found by Ray.
 
I wonder if he had them all written down somewhere with names and souvenirs and I also wonder if he ever used regulars more than once. It is strange none have come forward except for those few found by Ray.

A lot of them are junkies and could be dead without CB's involvement.
 
A lot of them are junkies and could be dead without CB's involvement.
Who are you talking of? All the dead victims? That isn't known so not sure why you'd assume that? They what walked all the way to these areas alone with no cars found and just got high and all died in various, same or similar places and circumstances? Or are you assuming all sex workers are junkies? As Regina pointed out, we aren't even sure the Asian male or Peaches were sex workers. That can't really be known when their identities aren't known nor can the idea they were junkies be known. So they came to be out there all on their own with no vehicle and OD'd? And in some cases somehow scattered their own body parts and in one case their own baby she dropped elsewhere?

As far as I know they are all considered homicides.

Sorry but you really lost me with this one.
 
I wonder if he had them all written down somewhere with names and souvenirs and I also wonder if he ever used regulars more than once. It is strange none have come forward except for those few found by Ray.
Well somewhere recently I read and I think it was in a link you provided in the last few days that as we know they have taken to interviewing sex workers in jail and so on, we've heard that before, but it also said such has yielded some useful tips or something like that. I can only imagine that means in relation to CB and their experiences with him or knowledge of him or others with him, etc.

We know it is not going to be a priority or even moral need of sex workers to feel they should go to the cops with info OR to trust them. However with the police going to them particularly if they are NOT under threat or will be in trouble themselves may yield something and I'm sure that's something none of them were ever doing over the last decades.

If there's certain "groups" or types that just don't want to be in the middle of something and particularly anything involving LE or appearing in court, etc. and one expects them to care and want to, I would say it would be very common to NOT want that re sex workers and to prefer to stay under the radar with their lives when it comes to that kind of ting.

On the other hand maybe CB was never with many that they didn't end up dead. Maybe he needed a once, twice or three times a year fix and killed them and would be good for a few months...

Maybe he NEVER had a complete sexual act and then just paid the woman and dropped her back off. Maybe he has bodies all over the U.S.

I don't know but I don't think it ath odd the ones that went to Ray and there's a real chance he's heard from a lot more but most didnt' have the corroborating details the ones he made the key ones did. We also have to remember no one knew who the killer was so any sex worker coming forward about any and all John's that scared them is just not going to happen. And again since he's been identified it seems even the ones they are talking to in the jails, prisons, etc. are yielding some info. So....?

I think there's a good chance he kept some info. We sure know he KNEW the names of some and bothered their families. Knew their real names. Perhaps only by cops naming victims in some cases, have we looked at that? Didn't he have one girls' phone in one case at least and that's how he had her contacts? Of course as we recently discussed the way older cases if he was responsible, the girls probably did not have cell phones. In some cases it seems he wanted them to leave them home. Wasn't that the case in Costello? Not sure but seems like it.

Did you ever know about the Long Island Lolita case? LI has certainly had its sex sh*t and men looking for it all and underaged to boot and so on. Well she had a pager so even way back there still were things like that to know when needed and where and so on or to then stop and call. No need to go into that case and she's long since married and never gotten into trouble again and so on. My point is about the pager, I'd have to look but pretty sure that was the 80s.

Kind of a sidetrack but I guess what I mean is he called friends and family to torment, he at least with the known ones had his ritual with burlap and with those he also had a bit of a dumping ground/area. Of course we don't know if he is responsible for all the others but I feel he well could be. I'm saying this because yes I believe he could keep souvenirs, not sure about names, perhaps but does he know all their names? Most don't advertise using their real name and some are unidentified (if he is the one responsible for say Peaches and Karen was only recently IDd. He may well have known who she was though if the cop knew who she was from knowing she was in jail. I have to wonder about that guy. Did CB actually have friends who knew... I mean he just put it all down to they were "playing a game" and then if it was Karen she ends up dead. He brought here there to CB, etc. Things to ponder there...

There is absolutely nothing that's a game with a woman running around outside naked in February in NY.

As far as regulars, that's a hard one to know too. I SUPPOSE he saw some that didn't end up in murder, I mean we know he swung with Asa at a club supposedly and he had sex with a cop at their home and that man left alive. But what WAS his regular thing? Even say the entire house and Vergata thing is false, which I don't believe it is but say it is, there is plenty showing CB wasn't only into women like those dead here. He searched Asians, he searched was it 9 or `10 year old blonde girls doing or having whatever and so on. I mean that's CHILD PEDO/PORN. And something that's never been said and I'm not saying it is the case but he had children in his own home and one was not his. And a daughter who apparently never launched, worked with dad and still lived at home in that small house. They all did through all the years these murders occurred from what we know, through all his years of escorts, and more. I mean that just blows the mind. At least it does for me. I mean how could even the kids not know some things or have been right there? I don't mean just the murders I mean dad's penchant for sex workers, and just a lot more. A what had to be odd relationship with mom and if swinging was true then there's all that.

WAndering but I do think there's a great chance of souvenirs and a record or just some other things, not sure what... Am I mixing up cases or was there anything about a storage unit in this one...? I dont' think so but then for some reason it rings a slight bell. I could be way wrong...

I suspect LE has things we don't know of too as far as others calling or stating once they saw CB, they recognized him from something. We know there are cases in is it SC where family or friends think for sure it was him with her mother, etc. I can only guess there's been some NY calls and just even not big info called in too of even someone who knew him and some conversation they had or who knows. My worry is IS LE and the prosecutor taking these things in and SERIOUSLY looking at them? I'd sure hope so. And ruling in or out?

I think it would be WISE to either give some corroboration to the Vergata swinging story or not. Is the cop denying it all and denying he ever dated this woman? Or has he confirmed at least that? Etc. They won't though. Maybe ever....

Apparently she and he haven't stayed in touch? As in she never called him first and said hey, I know it was a long time ago and we don't talk any more but do you remember that time we went to a couple's house and picked up that woman? Did she do that first? Nothing seems to indicate that. I guess though it was a long time ago and both went on with their lives but still I'd maybe try to reach out in a case like that.

Don't know what all she did in those days but she's a nurse now and he was a cop, narcotics right, at least was?

I wonder when ANYTHING MORE will come here as to info in the cases charged or investigation of all the others and these stories and so on? I worry with the NY mess of politics running even justice that this will ever go any further as to more cases or proving it can or can't be him and so on.
 
The POS probably helped them along. We don't know COD do we? Some of them were mothers.
I see no reason to believe their deaths were due to being junkies. Makes no sense. They didn't spread their own body parts nor drive selves to where found, etc. I think it's widely accepted just about all of them if not all are homicides.
 
I wonder if he had them all written down somewhere with names and souvenirs and I also wonder if he ever used regulars more than once. It is strange none have come forward except for those few found by Ray.

A lot of them are junkies and could be dead without CB's involvement.

Who are you talking of? All the dead victims? That isn't known so not sure why you'd assume that? They what walked all the way to these areas alone with no cars found and just got high and all died in various, same or similar places and circumstances? Or are you assuming all sex workers are junkies? As Regina pointed out, we aren't even sure the Asian male or Peaches were sex workers. That can't really be known when their identities aren't known nor can the idea they were junkies be known. So they came to be out there all on their own with no vehicle and OD'd? And in some cases somehow scattered their own body parts and in one case their own baby she dropped elsewhere?

As far as I know they are all considered homicides.

Sorry but you really lost me with this one.

I'm responding to @Tresir 's comment asking why more women haven't come forward.
 
While it could be true or false, I don't see where what she says doesn't make sense to you.
Really? You seemed to agree that the swinging angle of her story didn't make sense.
Anyway, nothing she claims re Vergata or RH makes sense to me.

The volume of this case and enormity and dates and of all the deaths and bodies, not just necessarily of CB all of them is hard to track. Were any of these deaths BEFORE Asa and CB were married? I guess I'd have to look at that. With Vergata she would have been pregnant it is figured and that wasn't long after they married if I recall. They were allegedly swinging at that time and prior.
I've read that they married in '96. (Btw, he was married once before and I don't know when that was but info is that at that time, he was working in Freeport, NY.)
Anyway, to my knowledge, the Asian male's murder could have occurred earlier than '96 but he's the earliest victim I'm aware of where there's a potential connection to RH.
 
Yeah even knowing they were sex workers when it isn't known who they were is impossible. I wonder if they do or have a clue. It was surprising they knew who Vergata was and held it after finding out. I mean I get things for investigative strategy but how would identification have alerted CB they were onto him especially with one hey haven't attributed to hi...
Well with the current ones, the fact he called relatives of the victims using the victims phones was a really dumb move, so that really must have helped to catch him. Plus the hair DNA and the vehicle identification additionally did it for him. I can't find your post now but you asked about him having storage and yes, he did - his Amityville storage facility was also searched.
 
Really? You seemed to agree that the swinging angle of her story didn't make sense.
Anyway, nothing she claims re Vergata or RH makes sense to me.


I've read that they married in '96. (Btw, he was married once before and I don't know when that was but info is that at that time, he was working in Freeport, NY.)
Anyway, to my knowledge, the Asian male's murder could have occurred earlier than '96 but he's the earliest victim I'm aware of where there's a potential connection to RH.
I think they married before '96 or were at least together in '96 because of the Vergata story and Asa not partaking due to being pregnant at the time.

He was married before yes, and the marriage reportedly broke up due to his liking for Craig's List escorts. I posted a link a long way back upthread.
 
I'm responding to @Tresir 's comment asking why more women haven't come forward.
So you weren't referring to the victims? How so when you say maybe CB had nothing to do with it and being a junkie killed them or implied such. If you're talking witnesses then of course that would relate to CB so your remarks seem to refer to the victims.
 
Really? You seemed to agree that the swinging angle of her story didn't make sense.
Anyway, nothing she claims re Vergata or RH makes sense to me.


I've read that they married in '96. (Btw, he was married once before and I don't know when that was but info is that at that time, he was working in Freeport, NY.)
Anyway, to my knowledge, the Asian male's murder could have occurred earlier than '96 but he's the earliest victim I'm aware of where there's a potential connection to RH.
When did I say that or what did I say? I don't have any problem believing the swinging story so if I came across otherwise I must have miswrote or some such. It all makes a pretty easy sense to me in fact.

I do allow for a story could be made up to match facts known, that most of us didn't know until a certain time but that others may have. However, she has got some real details that will either pan out and be corroborated or not. It all fits imo pretty well.

I knew he was married befor, no kids and he had hooker problems then if I recall.

She the Asian could have been before Vergata. Problem with the unknowns is no way to know when they went missing much less died. With Peaches, it oculdn't be beyond he baby's age.
 
Well with the current ones, the fact he called relatives of the victims using the victims phones was a really dumb move, so that really must have helped to catch him. Plus the hair DNA and the vehicle identification additionally did it for him. I can't find your post now but you asked about him having storage and yes, he did - his Amityville storage facility was also searched.
I thought so with the storage, thought he had some and that it was searched but I couldn't recall for sure and though it may have even been more than one storage unit and locations. Some case I followed the perp had a number of them and so that one was mixing in in my head and I couldn't recall the specifics with CB and storage unit.

Thank you for the answer, much appreciated.

Yeah he did some very dumb things without a doubt. I think these calls were the beginning of figuring out a LOT of things and when they found again the missed tip on CB and his vehicle, it then really rolled. They had a perp already narrowed to a joint connection wasn't it with Manhattan and Massapequa Park and more.

Even though these murders were how old and so much evidence could be gone or destroyed, I can only think they likely hit some pay dirt in their searches too. I don't know what but I'd guess a few things at least... How huge I also don't know but they already have a ton of other solid evidence for these four murders. Anything else is extra and hopefully also hints at others.
 
I think they married before '96 or were at least together in '96 because of the Vergata story and Asa not partaking due to being pregnant at the time.
Are you saying it's a fact that Asa was pregnant or that it's her story that Asa was pregnant (or what she said Asa told her)?
My understanding of what she said is that she didn't know why Asa didn't participate but thought it was because she's black.

That link contains so much inaccuracy, I wouldn't know where to start.
 
I asked who was swinging with whom and you answered with "that's true."
I have to find time and go back and see the context but I would assume I meant yeah they're swinging and this one with that one and who knows who with who, etc. That's swinging right?

It was said both were with CB although she THOUGHT she was is the way I first heard it and now says it more definitely but that her bf was. Asa abstained or so it sounded.

As to Karen who knows.

And I also may have meant at the club or any "get together" at someone's house. Again I'd have to see the context I said it in and I doubt I meant I doubted swinging was going on as I don't doubt that one bit. That's the best I can give ya with little time this morn left.
 

Forum statistics

Threads
3,010
Messages
241,058
Members
969
Latest member
SamiraMill
Back
Top Bottom