I agree with
@GrandmaBear 
I think it's highly unlikely. We need to know his whereabouts when these murders occurred. If he was in NY or somewhere else, well that answers that question.
Also, do they have the Route 29 killer's DNA?
I also believe that he has killed elsewhere. Perhaps a DNA match will show up eventually. I'm surprised one hasn't hit already.
Agreeing with ya I'm not a big fan of either.
I do think think this areal or all murders should be ignored there, as to possibly CB but I just didn't feel this podcast made a good case for it with the cases they talked of, etc. Maybe there is more that could help. DNA, anyone who saw the man describe him as talker or more hulking than most, etc.?
I do disagree with you on the sketch. The hair an eyes aren't "perfect", eyes COULD be his but the entire rest of the face is a dead ringer almost in match. Nose, cheeks, lips, all of half of it for sure and even eyes and brows could be.
And where's the details here? I mean maybe they don't have any? Is that his truck and the pics of someone with it, is that supposed to be the killer?
It is significant his mom lived there and that he traveled there and i wouldn't find it hard to believe he took advantage of being harder to catch when out of town, not a local and did kill.
But this failed to make much impact and all now I'd rather say YEAH a perp did this than go in favor of him but not convinced.
He was about hookers and swinging and Craigs List, etc. Did any of them lose their phones and then their families got strange calls from the alleged killer?
I guess he COULD have been like doing Craigslist or something and found some naive 75 year old woman (who did Craigslist really) and wanted to buy her buffet or car or something... And something similar with the man who pretended to be going to work but maybe was really selling something he didn't want wife to know about either so he could get $$$ hiding $$$ from her or to surprise her with a gift he bought with the $$$ or he was meeting a man for sex. I guess the two girls camping COULD have been advertising a good time on CL.
But all he talks of are so different than LI killings, ALL of them. I do believe he could have used different modus operandi in different places, any of SKs could but enough reason here isn't even given to get me on board.
Did you listen to it all? I almost don't think so as you'd be talking of the fact in two cases there were arrests and in one a conviction of more than one guy of which had to be released or were if not falsey convicted then at least not proven as the DNA didn't match. I can't recall offhand, I DID watch it all but the 75 year old I think three young men were arrested, two convicted and one was found not guilty. That's your cup of tea, false convictions HOWEVER, one of them DID confess. I can't recall which case had the other but someone was arrested and then let go before trial or anything. Most of these are so different that like I said they don't even seem to tie together in their own area. At least the ones outlined. How many are there with just Highway 29 and an attempt to get them to pull over? Because the ones he went into detail about weren't those for the most part. And even then not much detail nor reason to believe they were connected.
I do agree it should not be ignored. I do think there is some DNA in a couple podcaster's other ones, not sure on the actual highway and pullover attempts or death on Hwy 29 if there is any. And not sure of what kind of DNA. I think DNA cleared the guys in the one case.
You know if this was not in the very years he was murdering in LI and if it was long before, I'd wonder more as he may have been trying to experiment in finding victims and how to do so. BUT I do believe he is smart enough to change his way in different areas. But again it just doesn't gel for me and again IF the podcaster had stuck to deaths and attempts to get women to pull over and help them and ride with him, I'd perk up more but he didn't. He spent most of the show talking of these others that just don't fit that and in which it isn't even known a pero sounds the same, they are only the same general area.
BUT for me, MOST of the sketch matches. I can't ignore that. And mom did live there. And CB did visit and have freedom in another area, on the way and on the way back.
I expected the video to be all about Highway 29 and it wasn't. That's what is wrong. He tries to put in all these one offs that were probably something else all together and spends most of his show on those. And they are so different as to I can see one not fitting but not all so varied. 75 year old. Not a ONE in LI that relates to LISK even if ALL the others do end up relating. The man who dressed for work, went to breakfast, etc. doesn't fit. And the two women camping don't either. They don't even scream Highway 29 and someone getting someone to pull over, they all don't match the others in their own neck of the woods.
Again I'm not ignoring it but I'm not sold. Maybe the place this guy gets a lot of his stuff from has better coverage on it and reasons. I would wonder about the one I recall truly murdered and looked petite, almost the first one in the show mentioned. It got my intrigue in the begiining but then it lost me on all of the rest or failed to make them seem connected. There WERE women who did not pull over, etc. who described vehicle and man. None though talked of size OR the podcaster doesn't have that info or failed to share it BUT to be fair tellling height or size when behind a wheel and not getting out standing, etc. wouldn't be so easy. You wouldn't be likely a great eyewitness if iyou ended up safe, never pulled over and just played it safe with being unsure if there was any bad intent.
I'm not dismissing it but I am not sold on it all by a long shot. i do think again if he'd stuck to highway and had some better info then it might be a different story for me. More detail about the vehicle for instance OR even his size.
Like I also said first time in this one, were their cell phones missing and someone then called contacts in the phone? Probably not just for the reason that far back most did not have cell phones. But there were phonebooks,and more, Caller ID, etc. Did they get strange or scary calls?
There's just too much unknown.
Like I said I did watch it and I am generally as all know, probably anti suspect in MOST cases but unless reason but if I feel enough exists I am and I admit it but this fails to get me there.
IT SHOULD BE though looked into as should ANY area his relatives lived, he traveled to, he owned property in, etc. THAT I do AGREE with and not dismissed without proof positive it to the other side.
I don't have a BIT of a problem he committed murders or attempted to everywhere he went, traveled to or had opportunity and time and had residences. I think there may be some in every such area or in some areas. And I dont' even doubt he may have with wife and kids along. We don't know it is fact but from what Asa looks like and her hairs and more and Ray's affidavits, etc. I can even see Asa saying sure Rex, I and kids will stay with grandma and you just take a drive and go DO you. I've got this.
If they keep at it and get beyond at some point the first 3/4 and his history and so forth, AND do not just assume that's it, this case/perp is going to have things coming out for years. I don't mean he will share it, I mean cases, other victims, other places, etc.
\He may well be the traffic driving guy in mom's area, who knows, but again the failure was all these other odd cases. I'd lean to the 75 year old was someone who knew her age and where she lived.
NONE of the cases he talked of seem sexual. Other than the attempts on the highway and the one woman he killed. Or of getting off on them/torture, etc.
The guy too, I guess he could have been gay and meeting someone but wife says no and not a single indication to hint that way PLUS why does it have to be CB?
I will say this
@Tresir he may well have done something in this area or at least to one or two or was attempting to get them to pull over if THAT was even him but he should has stuck to that kind of Highway 29 stuff and what he could find rather than add these others that really don't fit imo. TWO of which had arrests and one convictions.
The highway stuff piques my interest, with the women. i expected it to be mostly about that but it wasn't.
www.crimewatchers.net
